Santa Stakeout

Guys, we did it. We made it through the first weekend of Christmas movies. How are we feeling? Angry that there’s still Halloween and Fall decor in our houses? While all our perfectly good Christmas decorations continue to collect dust? Just me? Okay. Well I think I speak for all of us when I say Santa Stakeout was the most anticipated movie of the weekend. One of our newer Hallmark Queens, Tamara Mowry stars alongside Paulmark Campbell HIMSELF. We all knew we were IN FOR IT. So let’s get after it.


The movie begins with a CRIME! Someone stealing artwork while Christmas parties are happening. What could be happening?

Tanya, our leading lady, leaves her INSANELY DECORATED HOUSE in the cutest jacket. Tanya is new to Denver but her sister lives there so she tells her neighbor she’ll be spending Christmas with her. Amy, Tanya’s sister, is getting married. Which means, unfortunately, Amy’s new in laws invited them to spend Christmas in Aspen. Amy tries to invite Tanya along but she is a hard pass on that. Tanya is a good sport and encourages her to go. She will be so busy with work anyway.

At work, Tanya greets her desk mate, Detective Ryan Anderson. Tanya’s desk is DECKED TO THE MAX with Christmas decor. Ryan’s desk is sparse. He makes sure to remind her that she’s a rookie detective. And he’s a grizzled old one, of course. Ryan tells her he plans to spend Christmas watching football with “the boys.” Then Tamara realizes he ate all her advent chocolate. After some more office nonsense, those two get called into their captain’s office. There is a hilarious bit with the captain’s bumbling assistant Talbot buying the wrong kind of fishing rods and fumbling around with them in the office. Then Talbot says normally the only fishing he does is for compliments.

The chief brings them in on a new case. Tanya realizes the same Santa is in all the photos from the three places that were robbed. Then, she and Ryan compete to find out details about the Santa. The chief sends them to check out this Santa together.

Ryan’s car is a mess. They park out front of his house, which looks to be decorated EXACTLY like Tanya’s. Boy they have DIFFERENT PHILOSOPHIES about detective work that’s for sure. They observe Francis Miller (the suspected thief) exchanging tools with someone in his driveway.

They meet up with their chief at a Christmas Festival for some reason and give him the rundown of what they saw. They want to search his house but don’t have enough evidence for a search warrant. They want to do some real surveillance to gather that evidence. They want to do a stakeout from the house for rent next door to Millers. The Captain tells them they are partners on this case and will do the stakeout together and they both vehemently object. He reminds them that he deserves that daquiri he is so close to getting upon retirement. Talbot collapses behind them trying to get wrapping paper.

They unpack at the house. Tanya has a full suitcase of Christmas decorations. They sort out their sleeping arrangements. Tanya will be upstairs because Ryan is a LOUD walker. Tanya also immediately comments on Ryan’s SLOPPINESS. She gets right to work snapping pictures of Miller’s house while Ryan lounges around.

Ryan focuses on the important thing, which is ordering lunch. Tanya peeks out the window and notices a suspicious delivery at Miller’s house. She heads outside while Ryan painstakingly tries to get Talbot to understand his lunch order. Tanya snaps a picture of the package and heads back to the house. She is locked out. As she slams on the door to get Ryan’s attention, an elderly man, Stanley out for a walk notices her. She keeps trying to shake him off but he is RELENTLESS. When Ryan finally lets her in, they immediately start bickering and Stanley thinks they are the newlywed couple that looked at the house earlier. Somehow they end up introducing themselves with fake names and wind up on the radar of the neighborhood Christmas committee.

Inside, Ryan is livid. But Tanya thinks this could all work in their favor because now they can get to know Miller and possibly be invited in to his house, like a vampire. Ryan finally agrees. Okay Paul C’s eyebrows deserve their own acting award in this movie because they are WORKING. HARD.

Tanya talks Ryan into getting a tree because now they have to actually commit to this cover story instead of hiding out all week in the house. Tanya wants to like fully pick an actual tree rather than just grabbing the first one they see. Poor Talbot is watching the house while they’re gone and Ryan is not confident in his surveillance abilities. I’m not confident in Talbot’s ability to like, function as a human. Ryan wants to just grab whatever tree and I can sympathize with that. He keeps trying to wave the worker over to bag one up. Ryan asks Tanya why she’s obsessed with Christmas and she says she misses Christmas in Wisconsin, where she’s from. Ryan says he liked Christmas until he got divorced. GETTING TO KNOW EACH OTHER.

Tanya tells Ryan she already wrote back stories for them! They finally pick a tree and head back to the house. They work on decorating the tree instead of watching Miller’s house. A delivery of lawn ornaments arrives. Ryan goes full Clark Griswold in the front yard with the reindeer. Up close, it appears there there is visibly fake cotton stuffing material on the shrubbery. They try to snoop on Miller while they put up lights and get caught by Miller. He tells Ryan and Tanya was about to bring over a fruitcake. Bullet dodged, I’d say! Tasha tells Miller that they want to join the Christmas committee. Tanya tells Ryan to check all the bulbs on Mr. Miller’s house as a “thank you” for the fruitcake. And also they can snoop through the windows of his house that way.

The next day, Tanya makes them both giant cups of something with whipped cream and a cinnamon stick. She calls it Santa coffee. I am definitely going to try it!! Tanya notices Ryan trying to shop for his niece. So far he’s thinking pink pepper spray.

Tanya starts sharing memories of visiting her grandma. She tells Ryan that her dad was a chief of police back home and applied for a job in Denver so she could prove that she could make detective on her own. Tanya decides to head out to meet with a Santa for hire company? She asks, Lois, the owner of the company, about Francis Miller. She knows him immediately and says he is their most popular person. He also books his own jobs separately but everyone likes him. She promises to provide Tanya with a list of jobs he’s been given through this company.

Later, Tanya goes shopping with her sister at a beautiful Christmas market. Maybe the same one from earlier. Amy asks about Ryan. Tanya admits he is symmetrical.

That night is the neighborhood Christmas Committee potluck. Tanya wants a fully immersive undercover experience. She shows Ryan the matching ugly Christmas sweaters she got them for the party. Guys, I’ve been married for over ten years and I don’t think even in our newlywed year(s) could I have convinced my husband to wear MATCHING ugly Christmas sweaters. I don’t think I could get him to wear matching ANYTHING.

They head to the party. Stanley is wearing a great sweater of his own, unironically. We learn Stanley is a walking encyclopedia of all things Christmas. Then we learn that Stanley owns an art and antiques shop. Oh DOES HE? I wonder where he gets all the art he sells? Ryan introduces himself as a chiropractor. Stanley asks for an “adjustment.” Ryan is basically like, sure how hard can it be? And he just gets right in there and cracks Stanley’s back. I’m dying. They meet the rest of the whole cast of characters in the neighborhood. GUYS these people are WILD. I think one of the ladies, Alicia, is openly flirting with Ryan. At dinner, Miller shares about how much his wife loved Christmas and that gave him the idea to keep the Christmas spirit alive.

When asked how they met, Ryan and Tanya try to just keep making their whole relationship story wilder and wilder. Later, Tanya gets to snooping in an office under the guise of using the bathroom. Nothing like a casual little illegal search to taint their WHOLE CASE. Miller catches her and helps her find her way out. Later, Ryan steals the show by leading the gang through some carols. Before everyone leaves, Ryan wants to take a picture of the whole group.

Miller pulls Ryan aside for a nice encouraging chat. Then Stanley’s wife points out that Ryan and Tanya are under the mistletoe so they have to kiss. They try to get out of it but they end up forced to! Sometimes I think about this in these movies and I think about what I would do if I was forced into that situation and how much I would just DIE.

They realize on their way out that they may have misjudged each other and try not to be awkward about kissing each other.

Back at home, they have a little bulletin board set up like all the good mystery movies have. Trying to connect all the dots in the investigation. They also caught on to Alicia being in to Ryan. Ryan asks if they’re looking at an evidence board or a Christmas collage. I love it.

Tanya says the neighborhood reminds her of Christmas in Wisconsin. I wonder why she didn’t plan to go home and see her dad? Ryan says that he had good Christmases growing up too. But now, Ryan’s life is basically a HUGE bummer. Tanya tells him she was engaged but it didn’t work out. After that little heart to heart, they notice something suspicious outside. Ryan recognizes the driver, Finley, that picks up Miller as another former felon. They decide to follow them. Guys they’re terrible at following people. And of course lose Francis immediately.

At this point my husband decides to pop in, notices Francis and wonders if he’s going rat somebody out for a steak dinner. I remind him that’s a different movie though who knows what is yet to happen in this one.

Francis returns with Finley’s backpack. They don’t know where they went or what’s in the bag. SOLID DETECTIVE WORK GUYS. Luckily, Tanya figures out where the next hit will be. To celebrate a break in the case, Ryan whips out some hard eggnog he just had all ready to go. It is quite strong apparently! Apparently, instead of doing additional detective, stakeout work, they need to finish decorating the tree. Ryan cranks up his music and misses a call from Talbot. Then they get in a tinsel fight. LOTS OF INVESTIGATING getting done around here. Talbot arrives through the UNLOCKED back door. Apparently he is supposed to get an update on the case for the captain. He has snow all over himself and had just a bear of a time getting in. Talbot tells them there’s been another break in. How did they miss him? Oh I don’t know. Maybe it was when they were decorating the house or having their heart to hearts, or through their failed pursuit of Miller earlier. Tanya takes the blame. Talbot kind of snoops around and it makes me wonder if he’s up to something. (Spoiler, he’s not. Just a weird guy.) Poor Talbot asks for hot chocolate and Ryan grouchily tells him no they don’t have any of that stuff.

Later, neighborhood committee does some caroling together. At one house, Ryan gets super into the sprit of caroling and drops his badge on the ground. Tanya creates a scene by singing a beautiful solo so he can pick it up. Alicia and her boyfriend or husband ask if he dropped a police badge. Tanya covers quickly and says it’s part of a Halloween costume. Alicia hits on Ryan again. After caroling, it’s time for the cutest little hot chocolate party. Ryan happens to start chatting with someone at the hot chocolate party that WENT TO COLLEGE IN TALLAHASSEE. Just like where THEY ALLEGEDLY MOVED FROM. Tanya swoops in and drops from Tallahassee knowledge.

Then Tanya and Ryan have a nice little heart to heart away from the crowd at the hot chocolate party. You can imagine the gist. I don’t need to relay that all here for you. As they leave, Miller says he’s on to them…being professional signers. Then Stanley and his wife give them a framed photo of the picture they took as a group.

Back at home, they eat some of Ryan’s gingerbread cookies. He says the secret is to brown the butter. Guys, I’m not sure if you can do that. Unless you brown the butter and then wait for it to resolidify? Melted butter would not work in a rolled cookie but I’M GONNA LOOK IT UP OKAY. Well, color me surprised. I looked it up. And many browned butter gingerbread cookie recipes exist in the wild. Am I going to make them? ABSOLUTELY. Maybe even this week.

While they chat away eating cookies, their motion detector goes off. Finally they are going to catch ol Miller in the act. FINLEY is back again. They creep to the back yard to see what’s up. They overhear Miller and Finley chatting and Ryan falls right into the fence like an IDIOT. Are they the worst detectives on the planet? Miller asks what they are up to? And they come up with some lame story to cover their tracks. Ryan says that was close but it actually wasn’t. They totally blew it!

Later, it’s time for charades with the Christmas committee. Hallmark seems obsessed with charades this year. Tanya and Ryan just crush everyone in charades. Later, Miller gives Ryan some good relationship advice. SO IS HE A BAD GUY or what’s going on here? Wait were they just playing charades in the middle of the day? Who has time for that? ALL these people? As they walk out, Ryan wonders if they’re wrong, considering Miller is SO nice all the time. They have a cocktail party tomorrow and they are hoping to catch old Miller in the act.

Tanya talks to her sister on the phone and her sister KNOWS SOMETHING IS UP with her and Ryan. Ryan comes up to show her their costumes for the cocktail party. It’s not good.

Oh no, they are dressed in the most absurd ELF COSTUMES. Tanya is walking in with her head held high and Ryan is just a dejected shell of a man. And I think his top is too small. Poor Talbot is in a nutcracker costume. So this is not a neighborhood party. Miller will be there working as Santa. I get it now. The party host shows off a fancy expensive Fabergé egg ornament on display in the center of the room. That’s what they think will be stolen. Then Ryan asks Tanya to dance. Are these two going to do even one second of actual work? Tanya tells Ryan she is going to miss working on this assignment. Ryan says he’s going to MISS THE COMPANY. WELL DANG GIRL. Ryan says, after all this is said and done, how would you like to…and then Tanya interrupts him and says “I’d love to!” And I just need a moment. And well, guess what. All that silliness causes them to get distracted and all of a sudden, Miller is missing and the lights go out. The ornament doesn’t get stolen but two Van Gogh art pieces were stolen. Like what? Does anyone even have those in their house?

All of a sudden, these guys have a warrant to search Miller’s house and car. They lift his tailgate and find one tiny little painting. Francis doesn’t know WHAT is going on or how it got there. The captain shows up basically in a Hawaiian shirt and flip flops and says they need to wrap this case up. The captain take them off the case too. I mean, I don’t think anyone is surprised there.

The next day, Miller is in an interrogation room but just wants to talk to Ryan and Tanya. He maintains his innocence throughout. Miller talks about his wife Kathy and says he tries to give second chances to people who need them which is why he was working with Finley. He and Finley were fixing up a house for someone who couldn’t afford it and was trying to keep it anonymous. Well, that is a nice and tidy explanation for all of that.

Later, Tanya packs up the ornaments at the rental house. Ryan shows up. Tanya tells him that Miller’s story checks out. They head back to the party host’s house. She tells the detectives that her friend Lois, the owner of that actor-for-hire company, recommended Miller for the party. Tanya thinks she might know what happened now.

They head back to Lois’s office. Lois just happens to be on her way to a vacation in Bali. That’s not suspicious! They ask why Lois didn’t include that last party on her list of parties Miller worked? And on and on with all the evidence they’ve gathered on her in the last…20 minutes or so. They basically worked the whole thing out. Lois tells them she was in Chicago during the other robberies but Tanya knows she didn’t use her return flights. Oh and they have some pretty damning photo evidence of her LOADING A PAINTING INTO Miller’s car. So maybe we should have just led with that? They arrest the heck out of ol Lois.

Back at the station, the captain is pleased. They feel so bad for Miller and what they put him through. Tanya asks her captain for some help. They must have helped him finish the house they were working on because in the next scene, they are just finishing it all up. HOW MUCH TIME HAS PASSED? How is it still Christmas Eve? As they all get ready to leave, Ryan and Tanya apologize again to Miller for dragging him into this whole investigation.

Miller walks up to his house to a surprise Christmas party in his honor. He’s very touched. Tanya and Ryan head out from the party and Tanya notices that the house next door has been rented for real. Then Ryan tells her that he rented the house next door. She says that’s the greatest Christmas present she’s ever gotten but why? I mean they wouldn’t be living there together yet, surely? Anyway, Tanya’s stoked and they KISS. And then head back to the party I guess.

So that’s that! I was really eager to watch this one and it was a lot of fun to watch. I’m not sure I buy Tanya and Ryan together as a couple but I would love to watch like a buddy cop version of this with these two. They were great together throughout the whole movie but it was one of those movies that I felt didn’t need the romance element to work. Also, bless their hearts, Ryan and Tanya might want to consider a different line of work because they were truly terrible at surveillance. But like I said, there were a lot of comedic moments which was great. I’ve listened to a few different interviews with Hallmark actors where they said that jokes are usually the first things to get cut in these movies. But based on this weekend’s movies, it seems like they might be moving away from that trend. That is great news all around!! What did you think of this one?

Christmas in My Heart

The only thing I know about this movie is that Luke McFarlane HAS A BEARD. And frankly, that’s all I need to know. So why don’t we just get after it. This is our first Movies and Mysteries movie and those usually have a few extra heartwarming feels. So we’ll see about that.

Beth, our lead is wearing the cutest blue plaid skirt and is stuck listening to her neighbor painstakingly practice his new instrument. No one leaves that experience unscathed. After it’s over, Beth plays a music box to reset and remembers her mom. Her dad comes in and tells her it doesn’t feel like Christmas yet. It sounds like this is their first Christmas without her.

Meanwhile, at an auto shop or rather, a garage, BEARDED LUKE, I mean Shawn works on an old car with a precocious youth. It is her daughter Katie. He asks her how music recital practice is going. She is pretty stressed so her dad offers to find her some extra help.

At a school, Beth’s dad Tim is asked to give a speech at the upcoming recital in honor of his wife, Johanna. Beth tries to coax him into doing it. He’s very reluctant. But it’s the inaugural year of her scholarship/instrument fund so he finally agrees.

Beth arrives at a music shop and her friend Sheila (by the way, how man women in their thirties do you know named Sheila?) asks her to file some music sheets while she goes to the back and gets something. Shawn arrives and asks to pick up some sheet music for Katie. Katie suggests a different song to help Katie practice. Then they bicker about whether country or classical music is better. How about NEITHER? Sheila returns and Shawn takes off. Sheila NOT SO SUBTLY whispers to Beth that Shawn is a famous country music star. And he even takes photos with a few fans on his way out the door. He takes a violin lesson flyer on his way out. Oh I wonder who the teacher is?

That night, Katie sees a text from Beth on her dad’s phone that says she’s not taking new clients. Katie takes matters into her own hands and convinces Beth to meet the following day by offering to pay her DOUBLE.

Downstairs, Shawn’s brother, no, his agent-arrives. He laments that Shawn doesn’t have a recording studio. And THEN Katie’s grandma Ruthie arrives. She is there to braid Katie’s hair.

Meanwhile, Beth hangs out with her dad and one of Shawn’s Christmas songs comes on the radio. Beth tells her dad she met him earlier that day. Her dad tells Beth that Shawn lost his wife a few years ago and that he always seemed like a nice guy. I think Johanna, Beth’s mom, knew him too but I missed that part.

Back at Shawn’s house, Katie asks her grandma to slick her hair back because she’s thinks it will be more professional. Her grandma encourages her to be herself! They have a really special grandma/granddaughter moment and I think I speak for everyone when I say I’m glad Ruthie is Katie’s grandma. Shawn arrives with hot chocolate and wants to talk to his mother in law privately. They talk about the recital. They talk about her growing up. Shawn feels stressed about balancing it all. Ruthie just very encouraging to him. She knows just what to say always.

Downstairs, Shawn wonders what his agent wants. He tells Shawn he has to get back to Nashville and record his new album. If he doesn’t he’ll be in breach of contract. So he’s got ALOT to think about. Shawn thinks the music left him but maybe a certain person will help it return?

OKAY HIS HOUSE. I would never leave either. Beth arrives and has the same reaction. The doorbell rings and Katie is like oh my violin teacher is here! Shawn is like WHAT. You can’t just hire whoever you want and give out our address! Obviously Shawn and Beth are both surprised to see each other at the door. Shawn is like wait are you even qualified and she’s like yeah kind of. I’m just a professional musician. He’s like well if you’re so good why are you advertising music lessons on a sad little flyer in a local music store? He is finally convinced when she tells her who her mom was.

Katie just says whatever she thinks and blurts out that Shawn doesn’t like music teachers. Shawn just wants the music to flow through you without practicing scales are whatever. Boy these two just could not be more different, am I right? Beth tells Shawn she really wasn’t going to take on any more students because she’s leaving after the holidays and basically admits the only reason she came is because Katie offered to pay her double. Beth doesn’t back down from that rate either. Dang, Beth. I guess a girl’s gotta eat! But side note, if she really wasn’t accepting new students, WHY WAS THAT DANG FLYER STILL UP?

Shawn has several requirements before offering to pay her TRIPLE but forgets his fourth point. Anyway, I think we are all on the same page about the music lessons and the exorbitant rate Beth will be paid. No blabbing about who she’s teaching or Shawn all over town or on social media. So that’s that.

The next morning, Sheila wants ALL THE INFO. Beth is not even gossiping with her BFF. Surely that doesn’t count? Isn’t there a little exclusion clause in all of these contracts that your best friend or sister doesn’t count for internal gossiping purposes only?

Anyway, Sheila is wearing a fantastic red coat and sweater but the jury is out on her bangs. Then Beth runs into an old teacher, Linda or something? Beth shares that she’s kind of struggled to settle in on a job. This woman invites Beth to join her that Saturday to play in a quartet with her. That sounds fun! So Beth gets to practicing. Do we know if Beth knows how to play the violin for real? We know Luke randomly can play the cello in real life right? Does he also play guitar? It’s all the same, right?

Beth’s dad asks her to take a quick practice break to show her that he put up on the Christmas tree. They have a nice moment and start to decorate it.

Back at the ranch, Shawn fumbles through playing the guitar. The agent (who’s name I NEVER catch) is like YES what’s that song called?! He’s like it’s nothing. The agent is apparently is just casually celebrating Hanukkah with Katie inside while Shawn is outside in his feelings. So that’s all fine.

Beth and her dad decorate their tree, looking at all the ornaments fondly. He tells Beth it will feel like Christmas after they visit one more tree.

At the ranch, Shawn’s agent teaches Katie how to make latkes. Guys that massive house. MASSIVE. And we have like an electric stove/oven set up? Wouldn’t he have like a giant gas range and built in ovens? How will he ever resell that thing?

Tim takes Beth takes her to the angel tree in town, which just seems to be in someone’s yard, out in the elements, where the requests can just blow away in the wind or whatever. They agree to take one for themselves and one more for her mom. And no one seems concerned about this tree’s location.

After dinner at the ranch, Katie rushes off to open a massive pile of Hanukkah presents and Mr. Agent wonders about their tree. Katie says her dad waits longer every year to put it up. Katie hopes they will put the tree up soon. Guys, Katie doesn’t really mind sharing whatever is in her heart and mind with any adult willing to listen. Is Shawn so absent a parent that this poor girl is just like starved for adult attention? Or, perhaps, do we have a childless adult writing an eleven year old girl’s dialogue for her? Either way, Shawn overhears.

Later, Shawn stops by a church to see Ruthie. She is conducting choir practice. She gives him a lot of great advice about just like not giving up. Honestly, Ruthie is stealing every scene she’s in. He heads out to get a tree to surprise Katie.

Shawn and Beth run into each other at the tree lot. She’s stocking up on garland, which is something I need to do. And Luke asks her to help him find a tree.

Beth and Shawn get to know each other more. Beth knows Shawn’s mother in law, Ruthie. They argue about classical and country again and he calls her a fiddler. Beth seemingly hears fiddling for the first time as he pulls up a song on his phone and she’s understandably taken aback. He plans to send her a playlist of fiddling. In return, she invites Shawn and Katie to her concert the following night to show Katie what pro violinists and classical music sound like.

Oh so we’re just jumping right to the concert Okay. People snap photos of Shawn as he tries to enter the concert. Correct me if I’m wrong, but I feel like people try not to bother celebrates in their hometown. Locals of that town anyway. Right? Tim kindly meets them at the entrance to help them find their seats. People are barely seated before the quartet gets right after it playing Christmas music. I love it. I could for real listen to this all day long.

Everyone is blown away and Beth tells ol Linda that she hasn’t played like that in years. Linda encourages her to apply for a second chair spot in the Chamber Orchestra. She catches up with Shawn and Katie outside. Shawn is very impressed and Katie is excited for their next lesson. Shawn looks back at her as he walks away.

That night Shawn sings in his barn. Are you telling me that Luke is both bearded and can sing for real?! I can’t. I can’t even. (If it’s true and not a recording of someone else.)

The next day Katie and Beth have a lesson. Katie wants to try some advice that Beth’s mom gave her. And it helps! They take a candy cane break and Beth asks why she chose the violin. Katie said it was so exciting to see Beth playing the violin because all the other ones she’d seen don’t look like her. Then Katie talks about all the fun stuff she did with her mom at Christmas. She just chatters away about all these sweet memories with her mom. Her dad forgets to do the fun stuff. Okay you guys I did not expect to be just sobbing through this movie.

Shawn arrives with ornaments and invites Beth to stay and decorate their tree. Then Shawn asks to meet her at the music store to help pick out a gift for Katie for Christmas. Then Ruthie arrives and they know who each other is but haven’t met yet I guess. Ruthie is AWARE of what is happening.

They must immediately leave the decorating situation and head right to the music store. Wow Shawn is just wearing that turtle neck out and about. They browse the records (some hipster in the Hallmark writers’ room is just OBSESSED with vinyl records apparently) and Beth fills Shawn in on her musical history. She tells him how hard it is to get a spot on in the Chamber Orchestra. Yes, that’s right. The Charleston, West Virginia, Chamber Orchestra is as difficult to get into as the Supreme Court. And it is her lifelong dream. I think he encourages her to go for it? They both talk about how they think they other inspires people. Sheila pops in at this point and I decide I really like her, bangs and all.

Beth arrives home to find her dad visibly distraught because they may not be able to buy all the instruments they promised the school. Beth is like, chill we literally set up an instrument fund and we’re going to be doing this every year! It will be fine. We’re going to like, still raise money.

Shawn and Katie work on their car some more. Shawn asks how Katie likes Beth and she just lights up and says she likes her a lot. She said she talked to Beth about her mom and just felt connected with her because they have so much in common. And I definitely don’t start tearing up. Then Shawn sort of bristles and gives TERRIBLE advice to Katie-he tells her not to let people in to quickly. Beth arrives and says she wants to make some angel tree toppers with Katie and Shawn gets very stern and wants to have a chat.

He doesn’t like that they talked about Katie’ mom. He sees it as a violation of their privacy to talk about her mom. Then, for some reason, even though they seem to have a decent conversation about this whole incident and might have been able to work through it, Beth is like maybe I should just quit and leave. Shawn is like okay, BYE!

Now Shawn has to deal with the fallout with Katie. Wow Katie has a really strong sense of her self and feelings. In this scene, for some reason, Shawn decides to try on a southern accent. I think maybe we should just go back to normal. I am not sure Katie and Shawn’s heart to heart gets anywhere but we’ll see.

Back at home, Beth practices some Christmas songs for her audition, which I feel is a bold choice for a formal audition for an Orchestra.

Moments later, it is time for Beth to audition. She just rips in to the Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy. After, they tell her she will need to audition again and she is competing with one other person. I think we all agree it wasn’t her best.

Back at the ranch, Katie shows Shawn an Angel tree topper she made. ALL BY HERSELF since Beth wasn’t allowed to help.

At some point in the future, the school music teacher makes an announcement at an outdoor Christmas Fair. The Fifth Graders give a mini concert. Katie is there and tells her dad she might be too nervous for the recital. Shawn says he used to get stage fright too. Then he finally gives some good advice to his child.

Katie runs up to Beth and says hi. Shawn says they would all love to have her back. He admits that he overreacted. YES YOU DID GIRLFRIEND. Then Beth’s dad shows up. Katie tells Tim she’s going to play with joy like Johanna always said. After the girls wander off, Tim asks Shawn if it ever gets easier. Just everyone stop crying for two seconds, okay?

Beth and Shawn do some musical work at their respective homes. Beth turns on her music box for inspo. Then her doorbell rings. What do you know, it’s Shawnie head. He is there to give her a better apology. He said he just finished a song and the first person he wanted to share it with was Beth. So now we get to hear Shawn sing. I’ll be honest if I’m Beth I feel so awkward. Do I look at him? Do I look another direction? Luckily here, Shawn’s eyes are closed. So if he did that the whole time it might be okay. Oh no. Now he’s looking right at her. Well better Beth than me. She seems into it. Beth loves the song. Then she jumps right into some constructive criticism. He can take it and tells her that his wife used to do that too.

Oh good. Shawn has a little southern accent again. Then he asks about her audition. He asks if he can take her somewhere. She’s like, sure it’s the middle of the workday so I’m not doing anything.

At church, Ruthie leads the choir in a really fun version of Go Tell It on the Mountain. Shawn has taken Beth there to watch them practice. He says Ruthie took him in and made him feel like family at some point. It doesn’t sound like he has great or maybe living parents? After the song, Shawn says he needs to leave to get Katie. Beth wants to stay and watch the choir more. Ruthie knows WHATS UP.

Okay dang it now it’s time for round two on the audition. The judge is pretty snarky with her previous song selection but for some reason I don’t think he’s allowed to call it by its official name because I swear he calls it the Russian Dance song? Or something like that? Luckily for all of us, she’s chosen a new song to play. We’re all hoping the pant ensemble will carry her through this audition. It is certainly moves the judges. And to be honest, seems much more complicated to play than the last song she chose. So why didn’t she do that from the get go? She’s about to walk off the stage when Linda calls her back. And she GOT THE JOB. Which surprises no one. NONE OF US ARE CRYING WHEN BETH TEARS UP.

Oh wow, a new twist. She has to be in a concert now in like a few days, which just so happens to be the same day as the school recital. Why would they want someone to hop into that concert after only a couple days of practice? No. And the PROCEEDS of the CHRISTMAS CONCERT FUND THE ENTIRE SEASON. WHAT NOW? So do they do no other concerts? Do they not charge for tickets for the rest of the year? Picture me gesturing to a punch of photos taped to a wall telling my grandma “that’s not how any of this works.” So Beth wonders how she will tell Katie.

Poor Katie. Shawn tells Katie he has to go to Nashville to record a new album. And then immediately after that, Beth tells Katie she can’t come to the recital. Katie says she is really nervous to play without her but she’s proud of Beth and this new opportunity. Then Katie drops the bomb that they are moving to Nashville. Just ALOT OF THINGS HAPPENING. It’s ALOT to take in. Beth asks Shawn about the move to Nashville. Guys, how long does it take to record an album? Surely he could go back and forth?

They both say how much they have appreciated each other and say goodbye to each other. And then they hug goodbye.

At the school, Sheila reveals she has LESS CHILL than we though and no discretion as she blabs that a “secret” angel donor who is definitely not Shawn donated a bunch of money to the recital/school.

Beth chats with Linda before the big Chamber concert. She agrees to go with Beth right after their concert ends to go catch the end of the school concert. What time are they both starting and how does the school one go longer? I would think the kid one would start and end earlier. But whatever. We already know Katie will go second to last. So WILL SHE MAKE IT?

Ruthie gives a great introduction speech for Tim to talk about Johanna and the instrument fund. Tim gives a speech that sounds even more impassioned with the orchestra playing Carol of the Bells in the background. Then, the girls get done at their concert and high tail it to the school. It’s Katie’s turn at the concert and she looks out in the audience. She has a couple false starts. So Shawn gets up to play guitar with her as Beth also starts playing her violin. Shawn walks up on stage to join Katie and tells her he’s nervous. She says, stop it, you love this (like his wife used to). Again, WILL YOU ALL JUST STOP CRYING. Oh geez now Ruthie is singing. And then the whole audience stands up and starts singing. And Katie finally can play a little on her own.

After the recital The whole crew hangs out together at Shawn’s house. Tim tells the group that they have enough money for 3 years worth of instruments. How many instruments need to be purchased annually? Just curious. Katie shows her grandma the angel tree topper and says it looks like her mom. GUYS. Just…don’t.

Guys I gotta be honest, I thought this movie was going to end at the recital but it keeps going. Shawn finds Katie at what must be the middle of the night at this point to tell her how proud he is of her. Beth wanders in for…who knows what reason. Now it’s Shawn and Beth’s turn to have a heart to heart.

Shawn invites Beth and Tim to join them for Christmas. And then he tells Beth that he’s not moving. He’s turning the barn into a music studio. Surely they can’t get that done before his current recording obligations can be met. How long are they willing to wait for this album for heaven’s sake?

Now, southern accent Shawn asks Beth on a date. But almost as soon as he tries it, we’re back to regular Shawn. And then they KISS! And that’s the end of that.

Okay so this was the first Hallmark Movies and Mysteries movie of the season. I think this is my favorite Luke Mcfarlane movie in recent memory. Despite the random scenes of attempting a southern accent, I think he is doing his best work. I don’t think I’ve seen Heather Hemmens in any Hallmark things but would love to see her more. I generally don’t like the more serious ones as much as the silly light hearted ones because, well, they’re harder to make jokes about. But I did enjoy watching this and loved the whole story. What did you think?

Boyfriends of Christmas Past

Okay so here we are again, back for more. No warming up. No time to get acclimated. We have just literally and figuratively dove (dived?) head first into Christmas movie season. Do you see me complaining? Maybe. But again, WE. DON’T. HAVE. TIME. So let’s go.

Our movie opens in a very cute House with nice tall ceilings and enough Christmas decor to kill a horse. A group of friends are playing Christmas themed charades.  Lauren and Nate are on a team.

Everyone is really competitive but Lauren and Nate as a team are next level. They are GOOD. And Nate has gone to the trouble of making some championship hat that note they’ve won this sacred competition for third years running. Wait, they are not dating? One of the guys asked Lauren about her date. Lauren tells them she was too busy and cancelled the date. Apparently he didn’t get her sense of humor. She is a fan of PUNS and he just let himself out.

Later, Nate and Lauren (lots of Nates this year, it feels) walk home together. Nate invites her to some big party. He is TRYING IT. Minutes in and he is at WORK to get out of the friend zone. Lauren agrees to go with him. Oh poor Nate. Lauren is just oblivious. Reminds me of my sister. All through high school and college that dumb idiot would befriend these perfectly nice guys and before she knew it, they were confessing their undying love for her and EVERY TIME she would be just AGHAST that such a thing could happen. And then they all sadly sat around a table at her wedding commiserating together about what might have been.

Nate gets serious. But just as soon as he begins, he chickens out and then pretends to feel passionately about pepperoni and pineapple on pizza. I don’t remember where we land on that. For the record, if anyone is keeping a record, my husband is pro. This is his literal go to order.

At Lauren’s office the next day, the girls are tasked with rebranding for a bakeware company. Well, well, well. The company wants to hear new pitches by Christmas Eve. Everyone needs to submit their own pitches and the best one will be submitted to the company. I wonder if they shouldn’t submit all of them unless one is truly terrible? Let the company decide? But I don’t know how marketing works.

Her friend at work, SUZE (is what I’m calling her) is like hey you and Nate are a great team and he shares your sense of humor, in that the only thing you find funny is puns. Lauren is like as if!

Then Lauren does some marketing work from her standing desk. She calls it a day at 1 pm to go Christmas shopping with Nate. I guess that Christmas Eve deadline isn’t holding her back. No, I guess it’s just her lunch hour. Sweet Nate is planning a Christmas party for some underprivileged children. I don’t know what the circumstances of these kids are but this seems great. Boy these two are just cracking jokes right and left. They have the same sense of humor! Did anyone mention that yet? Nate says he ordered pizza the way she likes it and got her favorite Pinot. He tells her it would just be them decorating the tree at the community center and so she feels weird and bails.

Later, she helps her parents decorate their tree. Well, her dad and stepmom. Her dad asks if she’s talked to her mom lately. Her mom is not present. She spends her time traveling from one place to another. Her stepmom seems Christmas obsessed and loves to do all the things that moms like to do-bake, wear Christmas aprons; you know, traditional MOM STUFF. Lauren’s dad asks if Nate will be joining them for Christmas. He grew up in foster care and now helps foster kids. We don’t have time to dwell on this because Lauren is really digging in on Nate being a friend and nothing more. EVERYONE AROUND HER IS TRYING SO HARD. Lauren will you learn?

Later, Lauren prays to a muffin tin, asking its spirit to speak to her for marketing purposes. Nate facetimes her and shows her the tree he sadly decorated all by himself. He asks how the pitch is going and she says the bakeware gods have remained silent. He said he sent her something to help her work. Gingerbread and hot chocolate, which basically arrives at the door on queue. What a guy, this Nate. My husband-is this a friendzone movie? Me, pausing the show so he can see the title. KEEP UP SIR.

Back at Lauren’s a blonde youth arrives and tells her to chill. She doesn’t recognize him. He’s like dude I’m your first boyfriend. As a YOUTH. But guys, if my boyfriend from when I was 15 showed up as his teenaged self, I would CERTAINLY be alarmed. BUT I would for sure know who he was. He basically looks the exact same. We learn she broke up with him AT WINTER FORMAL. Lauren. Honestly! Anyway, he’s here to help her in his little beanie perched delicately atop his blonde little head. I don’t know how hold Lauren is supposed to be but in my day, the teens wore their beanies fully on top of their heads. Tyler the teenage ghost tells her she’s about to be visited by 3 ex boyfriends before Christmas Eve. Hahahaa bless his little teen heart. He doesn’t remember his whole speech so he reads it from a text he wrote. Again, youths from my day and age were not typing out notes on our flip phones. Wait, am I an elderly person? Tyler disappears to make it home before his curfew and she wakes up. Jay pipes up and says, I feel like this has been done before. I say, hello have you ever heard of “A Christmas Carol?” That’s not it he says (not as politely as I typed, I might add.) But I think he’s thinking of that Jennifer Garner movie and it is the reverse.

The next day, Lauren tells Nate about her experience. Guys, I love that teal/hunter green suit jacket. They both ask each other why they haven’t dated in a while. They agree to “put themselves out there.” Wherever THERE is. Nate privately does NOT agree to this.

Back at work, Lauren decides to stalk ol Tyler from high school. Wow he has a cute little family and a cute dog. Then SUZE arrives and has a super cute outfit on too. Seriously I need a whole separate credit list of links to all the outfits at the end of each movie.

Suze leaves a toy for the toy drive with Lauren because she is too busy to go. The bakeware gods remain silent on marketing ideas.

That night at the community center, Nate wears a festive elf hat and demands the same from his employees, wait maybe it is the youths themselves. HOSTILE WORKOUT ENVIRONMENT. Then he does an embarrassing little rap for them. Lauren arrives with the stupidest toys in the entire world. Nate, visibly disappointed in her toy selection, puts Lauren to work wrapping other gifts and tries to quietly find a dumpster to stuff that giant ancient teddy bear. A woman arrives that seems very glad to meet Nate. She tells Nate she wants to get involved. YEAH SHE DOES. Lilly can’t be all bad. She has a lovely lavender jacket and sweater combo. Very into it. Lauren looks on and smirks. Nate seems happy to meet her too. Nate tells Lauren her toy is better than Lilly’s. Yeah, better in the trash!! Lauren stops wrapping her singular present to say high to some of the kids that hang at the youth center. These youths have LESS CHILL THAN A HALLMARK MOM. NO CHILL. Lauren hears a skateboard and wonders if Tyler is back. Nate is like, other people skateboard. Why don’t you lie down, crazy lady.

The next day, the muffin tin refuses to speak to Lauren so she texts Nate to meet at a lovely Christmas market for coffee. They both reach for a piece of the pastry at the same time. Nate thinks they are having a MOMENT but Lauren is actually just finally hearing from the Spirit of the Muffin Tin. HORRIBLE TIMING, MUFFIN TIN. Nate tries to take her to a romantic restaurant to celebrate her pitch. Lauren shuts him down HARD. Lauren, you idiot.

That night, Lauren’s guitar playing college ex boyfriend, Jake, wakes her up at 2 AM. She is prepared to knock him unconscious with a muffin tin. There’s a pitch for a rebranding!

Anyway, Jake tells her to follow him. They are transported to their college library. Lauren looks at herself and while I wonder how she could look OLDER in the past, Lauren thinks she looks young. She reminds herself not to get bangs again. GIRL, SAME. I am not allowed. Jake arrives with a bunch of cookies. Jake asks if her mom is just as crazy about baking and Christmas. Lauren says she’s not that kind of mom but shuts down any more mom cat. Then they transport ahead one year. Jake is playing a Christmas song for her outside and reveals he’s wearing an ugly Christmas sweater. His mom got her one too! That’s cute. Jake says his mom already feels like she’s part of the family. He invites her to come home for Christmas with him. She doesn’t want to go. Apparently this is the first time he’s said he loves her. And obviously she says she is not ready for any of that. She then has a full on meltdown and breaks up with him. Current Jake asks why she really broke up with him. Lauren is like no it was just that I was super busy and not the deeply rooted trauma of my mom abandoning me. JUST BUSY. They transport to their old dorm. Good ol Nate arrives with gingerbread cookies and hot chocolate. Guys, the backwards hat is not going to make Nate look 21. Lauren says she’s looking forward to seeing her dad. Nate wonders if she’ll see her mom and Lauren says her mom doesn’t care about the holidays and left their family right before Christmas. Nate doesn’t have anywhere to go for Christmas. Jake makes some observations to present Lauren. Like how she totally shut Jake out when he asked about her mom but she opened right up to Nate. Lauren learns nothing.

The next morning Lauren tells Nate about the Jake ex boyfriend dream. Nate has no comment as to whether he liked Jake or not. Nate says he’ll see her tonight and she’s forgotten about decorating the town square.

Lauren tells Suze about her pitch. But SOMEONE ALREADY SUBMITTED THAT IDEA. Lauren tries not to panic. She shoves a few free office pastries into her mouth while she thinks. Lauren heads to her stepmom for more baking inspo. I am on the fence about Lauren’s sweater. Yung shares that she baked with her mom growing up and that is why she loves to do it now. Lauren tells her she wishes she has memories like that with her mom. Lauren’s dad is fantastic. That’s all.

That night, Lauren and Nate decorate the town square? I am not sure how that is any of their jobs but here we are. And then they have the saddest Christmas tree lighting Hallmark has ever seen. That tree is only like 10 feet tall? Where is this? Then, LILLY shows up. She is just shooting her shot at every opportunity. She wants to get coffee after the holidays. Lauren stands back and watches. IS LAUREN AN ACTUAL IDIOT. How can she not see that he likes her. Or that she likes him. Anyway, she says she just wants him to be happy. And he’s like but DO YOU REALLY.

As Lauren gets into bed I realize there is garland covering every square inch of her bed. So yeah I’m going to need to order more apparently. And the Christmas lights stay LIT. She prays to her muffin tin that no ex boyfriends visit her. Her prayers are ignored and a busy businessman is standing in her living room. Henry is here. Lauren is not interested in learning any lessons. Also how many pairs of actual pajamas does Lauren own?

Henry takes Lauren to a Christmas party in the past at his house. The first party they hosted together. Henry says he thought she could be “the one.” And present Lauren bristles. Also she is still rocking those bangs. Wow he asks her to move in with him. That is VERY EDGY for Hallmark. She tries not just melt into a puddle of anxiety. Nate arrives at the party with a girlfriend. She tells Nate about that whole moving in business and she tells Nate she thinks its too soon. Henry asks present Lauren if she notices anything about that little exchange. Lauren is still not learning any lessons. Henry then takes her to their ice skating date a few days later. She tells him she’s not ready to move in with him and she doesn’t see a future with him. Henry thinks she’s running away and then she literally skates away and crashes. Ghost Henry says he’s not surprised that she immediately calls Nate as she panics and sprints out from the ice rink. Henry reminds Lauren that she’s not learning ANY LESSONS. I’m glad SOMEONE IS SAYING IT. Will she learn anything from that teen and that muffin tin?

The next day, Lauren rehashes the dream with Suze. They are making gingerbread houses to impress her in-laws. Good luck doing that with a gingerbread house. They are apparently Christmas crazy. Suze wonders if she has a problem with commitment. UM HELLO. Where have you been all movie, SUZE? I like both their turtlenecks but I don’t think I could pull off the one SUZE is wearing. Suze is also like hi, have you met Nate?

That night they are all at some Christmas festival. I don’t remember what this is all for but there is a sad little banner that says “Winter Wonderland.” So I guess that’s what that is. Nate talks Lauren into a carriage ride. Poor Nate. When is he just going to give this all up? Oh and Lauren calls her self a hot chocoholic and says that doesn’t work does it? But Word doesn’t even think “chocoholic” is misspelled so I think it DOES work.

They have a nice chit chat on the ride and then hit a bump and she goes flying into him. She stays RIGHT UP IN HIS PERSONAL BUBBLE for entirely too long, But this gives Nate the courage to talk to her about his feelings. BUT AGAIN that is when the spirit of the muffin tin decides to speak to her about marketing. And then she comes up with her second unoriginal pitch idea. Lauren, maybe we should think about whether you have any other marketable skills.

Lauren has yet ANOTHER great set of pajamas and went an entire night with no visits from her ex boyfriends. Lauren tells her friend her got her idea in just under the wire. Lauren’s dumb idea wins the marketing pitch (even over her first unoriginal idea). Suze again brings up Nate. Lauren is now at least aware that Nate likes her. So that’s something. Suze does a little sneaky psychology to get Lauren to admit what a great guy Nate is. I still don’t understand what Suze’s job is. Anyway, now we have a montage of Lauren taking pics of her dad and stepmom in their kitchen to prepare for the big Christmas Eve pitch. Lauren and I are on the same page regarding whether we should say no to cake or not (The answer is-you never say no to cake).

Later, Nate has a great Christmas sweater of his own down at the Community Center. He texts Lauren asking whether she is still coming that night; to whatever it is that is happening down there. No, I think she is working late on her marketing pitch. Suze gets her whole presentation on a thumb drive. After chit chatting with Suze, she realizes she is WAY late to Nate’s thing. She rushes down and gives him the Christmas cards. What are the cards for? It’s the day before Christmas Eve? Nate is pretty bummed. He really lays into her and FOR ONCE a Hallmark lead DESERVES IT. And this sweet angel of a human, in spite of all she put him through today and every day FOR YEARS, he works up the courage to tell her how he feels. And then he says he can’t spend Christmas with her family. ARE YOU READY TO LEARN YOUR LESSON NOW LAUREN?!

Back at home, Lauren sits on her couch while sad music plays. She texts Nate and asks to talk. READ THE ROOM, LAUREN. She asks the muffin tin and Tyler not to send another boyfriend to visit. She plans to stay up all night to prevent it from happening. She obviously falls asleep and wakes up to WILLIAM. These poor ghosts are just quietly raging at the task they’ve been given. They head to the forests or mountains or something. She’s got a great coat on. Oh they went on a winter zip line trip! KILL ME. She hyperventilates up on the platform just like I would. She traveled a lot with ol William. And she apparently did tell William she loved him. Uh oh. I think William is going to propose to her on this zipline ledge. To be clear, this would not have gone over well for Ol Cal. I would have been in too much of a state of personal crisis at the idea of plunging to my death to consider a proposal. Guys, do not propose on a zipline ledge. It is a truly terrible idea. And, what do you know? I was right. So anyway, William gives the whole proposal speech to her but is all hooked in and can’t get down on one knee. She says she’s not ready to get married. William actually pushes her a little. He’s like, we’ve been together 3 years so when would you be ready? And then he accidentally falls or something and plunges down the zipline. Lauren “wakes up” and all the boys are there in the living room. They want to know whether she’s learned any lessons. Oh she did! Kind of.

They point out that she broke up with them all at Christmas and that Christmas seems to be a big trigger for her commitment issues. Lauren asks our little street youth a question about changing her ways before its too late. Sweet little teen Tyler has forgotten all the wisdom he’s imparted so far. But is capable enough to transport her one more time. The boys take her to the future. They are here to show her Nate on a date at that restaurant he wanted to take her to. And he is proposing to Lilly. He calls Lilly his best friend and Lauren yells, wait, I’m his best friend. So now Lauren has a mini panic attack about that. Why does she actually care though right now? Two days ago she was like yeah take her on a date! Marry her for all I care!

The next morning, Lauren meets her dad for coffee. She’s wearing a great teal dress. She tells her dad she’s been thinking and reflecting about her failed relationships. Now she’s worried she’s becoming just like her mom. He gives her some solid dad advice.

Back at her office, she looks at a picture of her and Nate. And then it’s time for her pitch…at 4 PM on Christmas. Is there ANYONE or ANY WORK being done at 4 pm on Christmas Eve across the US? I highly doubt it. But here we are, working in basically the middle of the night on Christmas Eve for the muffin tin and the bakeware gods. Lauren has a bit of an emotional crisis in the middle of her pitch. And then obviously has to leave righthissecond to tell Nate how she feels.

I’m not sure why she had to leave work for this party that was clearly in the evening but here she is with her lipstick a little smeared and a very lovely Christmas party dress. She tells him she doesn’t care about losing a client, but I wonder if the company she works for does? I’m wondering if literally everyone else who put their holiday plans on hold might be a little bit frustrated that she fled the meeting (and yet still went home and got TOTALLY READY) to tell her friend she liked him. Will there be consequences? Will the bakeware gods forgive her? We never know.

Anyway, in terms of her personal life, She FINALLY GETS HER HEAD SCREWED ON STRAIGHT and tells Nate he’s the love of her life. And they kiss right in the middle of all the youths. The youths all cheer and die of embarrassment. Then they had out Christmas presents to all the kids. Lauren wonders what happened to the giant stuffed bear she brought? Nate is like, Lauren, none of these teens want a stuffed bear.

Then, thankfully, Nate is at Lauren’s house for Christmas. Nate has a gift for Lauren. If he proposes after one day then I don’t think anyone will learn any lessons. WAIT HE IS. How much time has passed? OMG. Okay even I am a bit panicked at the speed of things at this point. But this crazy gal says yes! And I must say, Nate-dog picked a much better ring than William. And then Lauren sees her old boyfriends creeping outside, finally able to rest in peace or whatever they are going to do now.

Guys, this movie was a lot of fun to watch. I had a lot of fun yelling at Lauren while my husband snoozed away, blissfully unaware, on the couch. But, I do feel that Nate was too quick to forgive what at that point was a LIFETIME of selfishness on Lauren’s part. I think showing up late to that very important party was just not enough. And I do hope Lauren gets some professional help to deal with the trauma of her mother’s abandonment or are we considering Tyler the teenage ghost’s intervention as sufficient? Anyway, best of luck to those crazy kids. What did you think?

You, Me and the Christmas Tree

You guys, it’s here! Hallmark Countdown to Christmas 2021. We have a full week before Halloween but this is just our thing now and everyone is just going along with it. Some countries have neither Halloween nor Thanksgiving so it really isn’t UNHEARD of to put decorations out this early. Just saying. Anyway, I don’t feel like I’m overstating that this movie was HIGHLY ANTICIPATED. And we’ve only just begun so let’s get after it.

Our movie begins by taking us back in time a few ::cough:: decades. Young Olivia gets in trouble for having her nice clothes on and climbing a tree. She runs through the trees and suddenly is all grown up wearing the same outfit. Today she is a “Christmas Tree Whisperer” but she corrects the person, telling them she’s an “evergreen specialist” because it’s not a Christmas tree until someone decorates it.

Meanwhile, Jack is having trouble on his tree lot. Customers’ trees are just shriveling up right and left shortly after purchase. But the customers like him so much they won’t accept a refund. He promises to provide them with a replacement by Christmas eve. He doesn’t know what is happening!

Olivia has an actual degree in forestry so maybe there is something to her evergreen expertise. Most people use that degree for the working at the Forest Service, not helping sell Christmas trees but to each their own.

Her mom calls and wants to make sure she packs a specific outfit for the “gala” (of course) and on brand for all moms everywhere. She panics because she thought the Gala was cancelled. She was engaged and broke it off! Justin was too…something. Anyway, she doesn’t want to face all those people.

Meanwhile Jack’s mom(whose name I NEVER catch) is at his house…well, her house. She recently moved into a retirement community but she is still cooking there for poor lonely 40 something Jack. She’s got a Christmas apron on. He talks about trying to keep his family’s business in the black…and find out what’s wrong with the trees. His friends show up to eat his mom’s food. They bring a big jar of…alcohol? Maple syrup? Anyway, it’s a consolation for all the bad trees. He is calling a tree expert to figure out the problem. Oh is he?

Olivia is working in her little office and her coworker is wearing one of my favorite Christmas sweaters TO DATE. Olivia tells her friend that she’s “Christmased out” now. Her parents are A LOT. Olivia promises her friend she will try and have some Christmas cheer.

Jack calls Olivia for help with his trees. Olivia works at a college in their forestry program. This is ALL ADDING UP. Olivia, dodging her family obligations, jumps at the chance to check out his tree situation. Also, Jack gives directions and they actually say goodbye to each other! So yay for real phone conversations.

In Avon, as they both enter the roundabout, Ben drops his phone in his coffee and then they get in a little fender bender. She quickly realizes he is the person she’s supposed to meet. They’re kind of bickering about how much damage there really is to her car. Also, I’m not sure why she doesn’t immediately tell him when she realizes but maybe we’re trying to stretch out every last minute of this movie. She finally tells him. Sheesh. She tries to start her car and something drops down from underneath it. It is the TAILPIPE. Oh we’ve got a classic “stuck in a small town with car truck scenario.” GIDDYUP. Except, this time, Olivia is super stoked about it. The part won’t be here until tomorrow. Surprise, Surprise.

Ben takes her to the Avon Inn and it is decorated as beautifully as you all hope. Things in this hotel are more modern than years past. A CODE for a hotel room not a key! The front desk clerk is perky and helpful, telling Olivia about all the Christmas goings on in town. Olivia calls her mom to let her know what’s happening. Olivia’s mom continues to hold her phone at arm’s length while she talks. WHY. Olivia’s mom wonders if she should run a comb through her hair and change her outfit. MOMS am I right? My mom’s rebuttal: Sometimes moms just know when their kids need to run a comb through their hair.”

Olivia looks at the tree at the party in the lobby downstairs. There is a hot chocolate bar but boring wet sandwich Olivia wants hers PLAIN. She prefers things in their “natural state.” So she doesn’t even like Christmas trees to be decorated Also, hot chocolate is CERTAINLY great on its own. But if there are toppings, you MUST take some. Isn’t that a rule of hot chocolate bars? Olivia has a thought based on what she sees from the tree in the lobby. She says she’s going to do some more thinking and they can chat more tomorrow. She tries to head back upstairs and he encourages her to stay for caroling. They start singing O Christmas Tree but she still heads up to her room.

The next morning Jack and Olivia meet at the Christmas Tree Farm. She sees a handful of disappointed families. They exchange a few tree puns back and forth but Jack wins. Olivia observes that the trees look great, until they’re cut. So she asks to see a tree cut within two days. Jack’s friends Elliot and Kelly arrive. Kelly is wearing a FANTASTIC sweater. Wow. 2 for 2 on sweaters.

Kelly suggests some hard cider after hearing Olivia’s bummer of a Christmas memory. (She had to be fully glammed up before coming downstairs to see what Santa brought.) We all say out loud, isn’t it like 8 in the morning? She opts for regular cider and amazes them with her refined palette. Is that…vanilla? She wonders? They stare at her in awe. How does she know what vanilla tastes like? AMAZING. But she is a TOTAL nerd. Then she suggests that Jack diversify his inventory/crops and he shuts her down hard. Kelly and Elliot jump into wingman mode. We’re all here for it.

Another day another dollar. Jack’s mom has NO CHILL. As per usual. She rushes over the next morning to return that pencil she borrowed. Did I mention how great the house is decorated? Jack’s mom becomes wingman AGAIN and urges Olicia to join them for the “Christmas Cocktail Competition.” Jack’s mom wonders if he’s just afraid of losing. Olivia obviously knows about chemistry. So now it’s on. This is a new angle on competition and it seems fun!

Jack sees his mom flirting with a guy and wonders what’s going on. Nothing she says. Jack and Olivia square off. The only rule for the cocktail is that they have to use some of the cider in the drink. Jack and Olivia chit chat as they mix their drink. She is straight up using a chemistry set. Olivia shares she always felt happiest in the woods. JACK TOO.

Okay now it’s time to taste test. Elliot and Kelly get absolutely HAMMERED tasting all the drinks. Olivia also put pine needs in her drink. That seems gross! Jack goes by what feels right and Olivia goes by what is right. Boy they are just two peas aren’t they? Elliot and Kelly thinks Jack’s drink is truly awful. Olivia WINS. Is anyone surprised? I am, considering that pine need business. But what do I know. Wow. Olivia does a little victory dance. It’s…fine. I’m proud of her for doing it.

Dwayne, the Christmas tree lot competitor shows up to thank Jack for giving him more business.

Back at Jack’s house THERE IS GARLAND ON THE LIGHT FIXTURES. An ornament drops off one of the sad dying tree branches. Then Jack gives Olivia an overview of all the ornaments on the tree. They add a new special one every year. Olivia’s mom hires a decorator and chooses a theme every year. This year’s theme was supposed to be a Christmas wedding she admits. So then Olivia has to kind of talk through that whole mess. Then Jack sneezes. They wonder if he’s getting sick but it gives Olivia an idea. She wants to dig up a root ball with one of the trees. She agrees to stay one more night to figure this out. He knows why she’s really staying. They head out to cut down and dig up a tree. It starts to snow. Jack loves it. And to be honestly, they both get a little weird about the snow fall. Case in point, Olivia just wanders away and lays down in a sad little pile of snow. She says being in the trees is her favorite thing in the whole world. Jack stresses about his whole business going under. A little city cop strolls by and shines a flashlight in their eyes. Jack tells them they’re doing scientific research. The fifteen-year old-cop asks, “Oh is that what they’re calling it these days?” They die of embarrassment and I laugh out loud.

They both compete for who is more of a New Englander as they try not to slip on the ice and lift the tree into the truck. For some reason they bring the tree back to her hotel room. She vows to just stare at the tree all night. Surely she could set up a camera? They have a MOMENT as Jack leaves.

The next morning, Santa is downstairs meeting kids. Oh well what do you know, Jack is Santa. Olivia overslept and rushes downstairs to meet him. The candy set up in the lobby looks wonderful. Olivia knows her next step now apparently. She needs to bring the samples back to the lab on campus. Jack offers to drive her back to the campus because she’s so tired and that’s the only reason.

Back at the lab, she is running all the tests. For some reason, there are boxes and boxes of mistletoe in front of her office. They were supposed to be wedding favors. Why would they be delivered to her office though? They decide to take them back to his craft fair and sell them. Not going to bother trying to return them or see if they were sent in error? Okay. They now have to wait ten hours for the test results. Jack says he’s going to go nuts waiting. So she suggests they do some of the town’s Christmas activities.

Oh good. First up is gingerbread house building. MY FAVORITE. But there are NO TREES with which to decorate their ginger yard. What are they going to do? No tree cookie cutters or candy. They head back to the kitchen and I don’t know what their plan is but they do make some trees out of…I don’t know, the gingerbread walls? But by the time they come back someone has taken all the house pieces. They decide to make his tree lot instead. Olivia tries to temper his expectations for her work and ability to fix things. She mentions diversifying again. He thinks his dad would be so disappointed if he diversified. This gingerbread house activity was kind of a bust, in my view. So they move on to the next activity.

Did they have to construct a reindeer out of wood? I’m not sure, but the old barn is all ready for the craft fair I think. And then they wrap empty boxes. Then Jack gets an email from the mayor about the town’s Christmas Eve tree. Olivia wonders why they wait until Christmas Eve to light the tree. Jack tells a wonderful story about the town coming together during a power outage and storm and decorating a big tree in the town square. Very Whoville of them.

The mayor says he needs a tree by Tuesday. He says they can’t risk waiting until the last minute. He’s going to use Dwayne Colson’s tree instead. NO! He’s the worst! Jack asks that he wait and see if he can get the tree figured out by then. The mayor agrees.

Olivia gets a call from her mom. She wonders if Olivia is avoiding going home. Her mom has made a nail appointment for her. Olivia is like well I am SUPER BUSY with this tree mystery so BYE. Then Olivia gets the lab results. Still no answers! They now need a full genetic sequencing. That takes WEEKS to get done. She still doesn’t know how to save this year’s trees. He asks her to tell him what she’s really thinking. She says she’s worried because she doesn’t know how to save them.

Melissa, the Inn Manager, suggests Jack make an actual MOVE. He thinks its not the right time. We all disagree.

Upstairs, Olivia has a breakthrough.

Olivia shows up in the morning with an idea for Jack to try! She thinks she can come up with a plan to save the trees temporarily. She said she can make it seem like this whole thing never happened. And Jack says “except for the part where I met you because I could do that again and again.” OMG. I could watch THAT SCENE again and again. Jack wonders if she shouldn’t do this all back at the lab. And she is like, oh shoot yeah I’ll leave. And then they decide to do some of the craft fair outside so she can stay and work there. At this point my dad walks in and wonders, aghast- You didn’t tell me there was a craft fair in this movie? My mom replies, there is ALWAYS a Christmas Craft Fair.

Everyone loves having the craft fair outside. Who wouldn’t when it’s 100 degrees outside? Jack’s mom things its fate that Olivia’s here. Inside the barn, Olivia works away at her little slow release tree medicine. Jack comes and grabs her to hang out at the outdoor Christmas Craft Fair. We see Jack’s mom and Harry having a MOMENT.

Jack invites Olivia to go for a walk. They HOLD HANDS. Olivia has another breakthrough about the trees. She’s going to add some sap to her little concoction. And then she makes a little nutrient pellet. Now they just need a tree to test it on. They add it to the water of the tree at the house and wait. Olivia wants to wait up and see what happens. She tells Jack he doesn’t have to stay up but he wants to see what happens too.

The next morning, Olivia fell asleep on Jack’s shoulder and feels embarrassed. Jack’s mom and Harry arrive with some breakfast. Olivia tells them they won’t know if it worked for sure until later tonight. So, why did she have to wait all night? Then Elliot and Kelly arrive. They wonder if everyone is going to sit and stare at the tree all day. Jack’s mom wonders if this will impact her gift exchange party. Olivia says she doesn’t have a gift to exchange. Jack asks the friends to watch the tree while he and Olivia go pick out gifts to contribute.

They arrive at a very expensive looking boutique and Jack tells Olivia they can only spend $20. There is no way anything in that store is $20. Yet, they do each find something and have to keep it a secret from each other. Wow the store does gift wrapping.

Later, they do their white elephant gift exchange. Everyone takes turns explaining the rules. Olivia has never played this game? Bless her heart. Wow. Jack and Olivia picked the EXACT same thing at the store. A book about Christmas trees. Olivia gets a robe and slippers. How is that only $20? Anyway, she makes a great pun and swaps for the book. For some reason they swap identical books? And now Jack’s mom has prepared a yule log. They invite her to cut into it to find the ornament to hang on the tree. She resists because she’s not family but they all agree she is! She finds the ornament right away.

Jack’s mom gives Olivia some good advice about speaking up for herself. She says she can’t expect her parents to fix a problem they don’t even know he has. I mean, yeah is that the case? I didn’t realize. Anyway, Jack tells Olivia he trusts her to fix their tree problems. Kelly hopes the tree isn’t fixed quite yet so Olivia stays longer.

It’s time to check the trees! It worked! They hug and he picks her up. As a tall girl, this is something I’ve never been comfortable with. Olivia makes it awkward and asks for a double high five. But I felt that awkwardness in MY BONES.

Jack and Olivia pass out their tree pellets to all his customers to revive their trees. Olivia takes a look at a tree getting loaded into the back of a truck. She tells the tree good luck. It is the town tree. They get it all set up in the town square. The mayor is RELIEVED.

Olivia tells Jacks she is actually enjoying Christmas. She wants to take this feeling home with her. But she has to go home because her parents would never forgive her. But Jack wants her to stay for the Christmas Eve event. Olivia wonders what would happen after Christmas. She lives an hour away for heaven’s sake. And then they KISS. He asks to meet her there in the morning.

Back in her hotel, Olivia tells her mom that she’s going to stay in Avon and head home on Christmas morning. She is finally honest with her mom. She tells her they have ALOT to talk about. Maybe like 30 years of suppressed emotions? SOUNDS FUN. Actually, it sounds more like Festivus.

The next morning Olivia and Jack meet up at the town square. They are happy until they get a text. The tree in the town square is dead and brown. Dwayne arrives just in time to gloat. He says his tree will be there in a few hours to save the day. Olivia feels terrible. I wonder if Dwayne was up to some sabotage? Olivia then brings up diversifying Jack’s crops again. Then Olivia kind of has a little melt down about her own personal problems. So she just bails. She heads straight to the hotel to pack up. She slowly packs up her little mixology award and ornament from the yule log.

Back at the town square, Jack and his mom pack up ornaments and Dwayne asks to use them to put them on the good tree. Jack’s mom wonders where Olivia is. Jack tells her she left. She’s like why? She gets the whole run down from Jack. Her mom is like, this seems like manufactured drama. His mom wonders why he doesn’t diversify. Jack sings that song “Tradition” from Fiddler on the Roof. His mom is like, Jack you are a silly goose. So she encourages him to go after Olivia. Olivia is on her way out of town and is stuck in that same silly roundabout. She runs into her parents! They meet at the coffee shop.

She gets a little huffy with her parents about having tree branches in her hair. She goes on a little rant about how she’d like to celebrate Christmas. Her parents seem to take it all in and they apologize for making her feel bad about herself. They agree to revamp some of their traditions. Just like immediately. No push back. Then she tells them about Jack. She thinks she blew it with him and wants to just go home. Did they really just drive that whole way for a ten minute chat in the coffee shop? As Olivia walks to her car she hears two idiots bragging about helping Dwayne make sure he gets the town tree. Olivia sees all the weed killer in the back of their truck. She smartly gets a “selfie” with those two idiots and the weed killer displayed prominently in their truck. She runs to the town square and puts a little tree tablet in the soil and explains to the mayor what happened. Dwayne digs in and says they should still use one of his trees.

Our favorite little fifteen year old cop takes Dwayne down to the station.

Now it’s time for the special moment. Oh wait, Jack’s mom says “Tree now, Talk Later!” Haha so then it’s time to decorate the tree as a town. I hope she let her parents know. Oh they stayed! They don’t care about that silly old yacht club party. And Olivia is wearing the coat her mom loves so that’s all good. Then they meet Jack! They are now super cool, breezy parents. Olivia is like, yeah I was wrong about my parents for my whole childhood I guess. Jack tells her he IS going to do some diversifying of his crops. They have their silly little “ no I was wrong” chat and then they kiss again! Then the whole town counts down to the tree lighting. It looks beautiful despite the dead branches.

My mom and I agree this movie really got us in the Christmas spirit. It was SO Christmasy. There was a lot more comedy infused into this than a typical Hallmark Christmas movie and I loved Ben and Danica together. I don’t think I’ve seen a Benjamin Ayres movie I didn’t love, honestly. Cranberry Christmas was one of my faves last year. So yes, this was a great way to kick off Hallmark Christmas season and honestly gets me excited for the rest!! Let’s GO! What did you think?

Advice to Love By

Sorry for the delay my Hallmark pals. I am travelling this week so I had trouble getting to this one “on time.” I am also trying to charge up for THIS WEEKEND. I cannot believe it’s here. Granted, Christmas is still two months away but every store in town seems to be taking its cues from Hallmark. So, despite living in the PNW and still wearing flip flops on many occasions, it is beginning to look a lot like Christmas. But in Hallmarkland, it’s still “fall” so let’s get after this movie okay?

Our lead, Kendall is giving an interview on a talk show. The interviewer things she’s “hacked romance.” And she’s written a couple books on dating. She has a data driven approach to dating I think? Seems kind of like matchmaking. Like the kind you pay a lot of money for and they run you through their algorithm. Yes, her approach is facts over feelings. If the data supports it, anyone can be successful in a relationship without work or feelings to get in the way! She does some straight up match making in the interview with a couple of audience members. Wow. Can’t wait to see how that plays out. Then she gets asked about a “feelings based” love columnist. He’s an idiot, of course and his approach should NOT BE CONFUSED WITH ACTUAL DATING SCIENCE YOU GUYS.

Dr. Lovestruck watches the interview and obviously disagrees and wonders what the science of love even means. I wonder that myself. He wants to meet up with Kendall and set her straight. Nathan, Dr. Lovestruck’s Christian name, helps his pal Larry level up his anniversary weekend. I actually HATE his suggestion because it’s super cliché and corny but maybe this guy’s wife will like it. We’ll see.

Kendall debriefs with her friend or assistant, Ella or whatever. Ella would like to be set up with a random stranger in a television audience too too. Oh she is the editor. Forgive me Ella! Kendall needs to churn out another book. Didn’t she just finish one? But she is struggling to come up with another good idea.

Back at home, Kendall has ZERO book ideas. She reads some articles by Dr. Lovestruck for inspiration. His latest article is about “grand romantic gestures.” Kendall and I are on the same page here that they are dumb and can be meaningless. Kendall’s sister, Joy, is over and she is directing this rant to her. Her sister has a new boyfriend and asks Kendall to go easy on him when they meet. She is not sure she can. I’m not sure I can either. We’ll see about TYLER when we meet him, OKAY?

Meanwhile, Nate dog is in his boss’s office. His boss asks him to do an author profile on…KENDALL. He is not allowed to tell Kendall that he’s Dr. Lovestruck because it is supposed to be a secret. I wonder if that will be an issue later.

Kendall is at “Book Salad” for her book signing. The store owner, Grant is pretty dang cute. Ella is VERY interested. Oh, wait no she wanted Kendall to date him. Maybe Ella should give him a shot. Nathan shows up to listen too. Kendall reads from her book. We are all bored to tears. Nathan waits until the very end to get his book signed. He asks her to sign her book for “Larry.” He starts asking her about her book and she seems a little defensive. Kendall says her books are based on statistics. And he asks like where her idea came from. She doesn’t know! Ella recognizes Nathan as a reporter for the magazine. And then he says he wants to interview her for the magazine. So now the cat is a little out of the bag.

Grant the wet sandwich book store owner (he really is, bless his heart) comes by and Ella has to try and contain her drool. Kendall doesn’t like that Nathan called her “entertaining.” She thinks it’s condescending. Because IT IS.

Kendall stares at her blank white board at home again. No new book ideas! She decides to google Nathan instead and read some of the interviews he’s done.

The next day, they meet for coffee and Nathan somehow knows her order. That is so creepy. Like how would he possibly know that? Then, this cute older couple approaches them and thanks Nathan for their coffee. Kendall calls him “theatrical and thinks its all an act. I mean, now that she mentions it, it might be? But also, Kendall is a skeptical robot. And Nathan is a too in his feelings hippie, apparently. (Her words.)

The next day, Kendall has tons of new inspiration for her new book. She is going to experiment on herself this time! OH Kendall is going to “How to Lose a Guy in Ten Days” poor Nathan.

The next day, Nathan is getting coffee at work and gazing into space. Poor Larry updates him about his anniversary weekend. It was a disaster from top to bottom. His wife was allergic to the flowers (how would he not know that?) and their dinner got rained out. But luckily, Larry and his wife turn out to be good sports and said they ended up laughing it off and having a great time. Nathan seems overeager to get to know Kendall. Larry turns into Mrs. Potts and starts singing “There may be something there that wasn’t there before.”

Joy creeps up on Kendall at her house while she sketches out her mathematical equation/compatibility test to figure out how to make a relationship successful. She wants to see where things might come together or fall apart. It is a crazy Hallmark situation of course, but it is actually kind of interesting. I am here for it, for now.

That night, Kendall has dinner with her sister Joy and the boyfriend Tyler. They seem cute together. Kendall tries to get to know Tyler. He seems really nice. They say their relationship was “love at first sight.” But Kendall is like, girl no that’s not possible and can’t let it go. She explains that you get signs from your neuroreceptors, not your heart. BUT IT’S ALL IN YOUR BRAIN GUYS. Even your “heart feelings” are in your brain. Doesn’t anyone understand that? Your heart doesn’t actually feel feelings. Kendall essentially receives two hard eyerolls from Joy and Tyler in response.

Anyway, Kendall is wearing a fabulous pink suit for like a date/research thing with Nathan. Everyone is wearing jackets but it’s pretty green outside. So like is it fall? Is it early spring? Nathan’s jacket is suede. Is that a clue?

Both parties think they can make this about work instead of a relationship. I don’t think that’s going to work out very well!! Nathan gets a beautiful bouquet for Kendall, explaining to Larry that the only reason his parents are still married is because his dad buys his mom flowers once a month. Boy that’s pretty dark, Nathan.

Kendall heads back to Book Salad. Are we committed to that name? She is picking up some books. Poor wet sandwich Grant strolls by and talks about her personalizing books for sale. Oh Grant. Bless your heart. He wants some advice. Oh no. Is he talking about being interested in her? I can’t tell. It MIGHT BE ELLA. I hope so. I feel so uncomfortable. She tells him not to do anything and tells him to let her come to him. Oh what if he’s talking about Ella. Oh I hope this works out. I CAN’T TAKE THE SUSPENSE.

Kendall and Nathan run into each other and he hands her the flowers. He starts talking about the flowers and she straight up asks who writes the Dr. Lovestruck column. She just goes for it.  Wait, what is the vibe of his farmer’s market. DO I SEE A HINT OF FALL DÉCOR? A sad little pumpkin on a shelf? A solitary leaf garland from Michael’s? I’ll take it. Oh and a blurry fall colored mantle in the background. Then they hear bells. UH OH. Like what Ella says happens when you fall in love or something?

Then they have a lovely picnic lunch in the park. She says a bad break up got her into this biz. They talk about the different feelings in a new relationship and she turns into a robot. He thinks she’s too serious. SHE IS. And he is too distracted. I don’t know about that. She is just a straight up robot. Nathan suggests they do something fun that afternoon. They do more talking and getting to know each other. She guesses some core components of his personality pretty accurately. They go to a random outdoor drop in judo class. Just throw on some used gis and just get after it. They are literally on a clothing rack outside. Where did they change into them though? Gross. Kendall went to “judo camp” every summer. Anyway, they’re having a good time.

Kendall crosses some things off her white board in the relationship progression. Things are going according to plan I think?

The ladies at the publishing company are stoked about Kendall’s upcoming book. Then we find out that ELLA is dating someone. But it’s very new so she doesn’t want to talk about it. Where is poor Grant in the middle of this?

Nathan and Kendall’s next date is a ropes course or something? Kill me. No thank you. No book is worth doing a ropes court high above the ground. My palms are literally sweating as I watch this scene. She’s just sitting on a swinging board like 50 feet above the ground. I can’t. I can’t even watch them do this. No. Nathan is going to keep going? No Nathan! Think of your family. I’m dying.

They have a nice chat RIGHT NEXT TO A MOVING TRAIN. They say they are enjoying getting to know each other and he says he is glad she has nothing to hide. I think? It’s not like they can actually hear what the other is saying. So then Kendall immediately spills the beans on her book idea. It seemed like he was about to spill the Dr. Lovestruck secret too but he doesn’t. He wants to pick his own name in the book. I think they land on “Spike.” Are we sure about that one? And then we don’t circle back to Dr. Lovestruck. Hmm. Okay That probably won’t be a problem later.

Kendall chats with Joy while she does some painting right in the middle of her living room. Kendall shares that she’s bringing Nathan to the art show. Joy says there is something to gut feelings. Kendall says you can’t quantify that. Fair.

Nathan participates in a meeting and his boss calls poor Larry “Levi.” I must admit I found his name equally forgettable and didn’t realize it was Larry until AFTER this scene. Nathan’s boss loves his first draft of the Kendall profile. Nathan wants to give Kendall a heads up about Dr. Lovestruck before it goes to print. OOH and now we hear that Nathan might be up for a promotion. It’s a little late to bring up a promotion opportunity isn’t it? At least it isn’t “Junior Digital Print Editor” or whatever. After some chit chat with Larry, Nathan realizes he and Kendall are dating. KEEP UP GIRL. Then he basically talks himself out of telling Kendall that he’s Dr. Lovestruck.

Later, Kendall and Nate walk and eat seafood from a cardboard baskets.

That night, Kendall has dinner over at Joy’s house. Tyler is making vegan chili. Oof that bums me out. Tyler read Kendall’s book and thinks she’s got a point. Oh, Joy is the vegan and Tyler is trying his best. Okay that makes sense.

The next day? Kendall and Ella shop in an abandoned warehouse. Ella spills that she’s bringing a date to some Gala they’re all going to. I missed what this was. Is it for the magazine? No, Nathan is covering the Gala for the magazine. I have no idea what the Gala is for but it’s Hallmark so of course there’s a Gala.

Later, Nate dog is committed to that suede jacket and takes Kendall wine tasting. This extra playing the wine pourer is doing THE MOST. Just taking every opportunity. Kendall looks like she has a filter permanently applied to her face. I don’t hate it but she’s matte and everyone else is not. So it is noticeable to say the least. While Kendall and Nate chat about making relationships work, the couple Kendall set up in that television interview show up to tell her they’ve really hit it off! They’re like a total couple now. It’s only been a few weeks. Now it’s time for Kendall to make her choice on which wine she is going to buy? I think? Anyway Nate dog knew which one she’d pick. After the wine tasting, Nate takes her outside for a full fledged romantic dinner. Oh cute. He takes her hand.

Larry finds Nathan frozen in place at work the next day. He obviously really likes Kendall. Nate’s boss really likes the Dr. Lovestruck column. He doesn’t read them because he’s an expert on romance after being married three times. I didn’t notice he was a creep earlier.

That night is Joy’s art show. Things are going really well. Tyler is very supportive. Then Nate arrives. Oh it’s time to meet Joy. He grabs her hand! Later that night? Nate works on a new article for Dr. Lovestruck about meeting the family of the person you’re dating. Meanwhile, Kendall is on to step 4 in her relationship formula. These two crazy kids might just make it!

The next morning, Nate wants to chat with his boss. He mentions to Nate that he will be considered for the “Features Editor” opening. Oh! He like has the job already. And he didn’t even need to plan the company Christmas party to do it. Very exciting. And now someone else will take over as Dr. Lovestruck. I still can’t imagine that Kendall won’t be irrationally angry when she learns the truth. We’ve got about 15 minutes of movie left so anything is possible. Nathan texts Kendall and asks her to meet. At the restaurant, she orders an iced tea and they’re sitting outside. That’s a summer drink and they’re in Seattle. Okay and then somehow instead of telling her the truth about Dr. Lovestruck all kinds of things distract them. First, she learns about his promotion! Then she sees Ella and Grant together!

So I’m glad Grant ignored her advice or did he? Oh good they’re joining Nate and Kendall. So no discussion about the Dr. Lovestruck business. But we still have time. Not much. He chickens out of telling her after lunch. She invites him out to dinner.

Kendall gets the whole book proposal done and shares it with Ella. The title is “how it worked for me…” which means that she and Nathan are going to be in a real dating relationship. Ella is very happy for Kendall and suggests Nathan review Kendall’s book proposal. So she heads over there to show him. Is Nate finally going to fess up?

She sits down at Nathan’s kitchen table and sees a mark up of the Dr. Lovestruck column and a draft article up on his computer. Do nobody’s computer screens go to sleep in Hallmark movies? She is unsurprisingly very huffy. She’s like, hey I told you what I was doing why didn’t you extend me the same courtesy? He’s like girl chill out. But she’s got to be mad otherwise the movie would end too early.

So Kendall storms on home and tries half heartedly to erase her work on the white board. But she’s left the writing on too long so it doesn’t erase very well. So that’s kind of futile. Kind of like when you try to slam a door but your shirt gets caught on the handle. Kind of ruins the whole dramatic moment.

The next day, Kendall is still huffy. Joy arrives to save the day. Oh Joy doesn’t know what happened. Kendall says she has to throw the whole book out now but Joy is like no you love him. And just write the book so you can pay your bills. Why does only Kendall have like a filter effect on her face?

So tonight is a book Gala but what is the purpose? In fact it’s night 1 of a book gala. I DON’T GET IT. Kendall is wearing a super cute pink dress. Upon arrival, she immediately starts looking around for Nathan. She walks up the stairs and misses Nathan arriving. Nathan then enlists Larry’s help for a grand romantic gesture which as we all know, is on brand for him. The Gala kicks off with a Q&A with Kendall. They ask for a preview from her newest book. Kendall punts on some of the tougher questions by encouraging people to read the book. Like obviously. She is just barely getting started. Who reviewed this questions beforehand? Nathan immediately asks a question. Is anyone surprised that it’s a speech and not a question? WHOA he loves her? Well, luckily for all of us, everything is forgiven. He also likes the new book proposal. They kiss and then dance the night away.

Well, that was pretty cute. It was very silly but do I even need to say that at this point? They’re all silly. I liked these two. There was a little hint of fall and it was a unique story line. So yeah! Worth a watch! It was a nice way to close out the “Fall Harvest” series. What did you think?

South Beach Love

It’s 50ish degrees outside. I have a blanket on. I have a sweet and spicy tea. I am ready for a FALL movie.

Our lead, Sarah is working in a food truck, which she owns. Spoiler alert: It has a truly horrible name-Munch. Everyone is in the cutest fall sweaters. The leaves are all of these beautiful colors. Oh wait. NO. This is South Beach Love and Hallmark isn’t even trying to make it seem like fall. Sarah has committed to catering her niece’s quinceañera. They had to change the day but I’m not sure why.

Our other lead, Tony, is also getting booked for a quinceañera for his niece. He looks sadly out the window (where it is raining because of course) while on the phone. Something happened with “Anna.”

That night, Sarah learns she’s cooking for 150 people. And Lola’s grandma gives her some recipes to try. FUN! I bet Sarah loves the idea of practicing new recipes for her largest catering endeavor. They reminisce about Lola’s mom’s (Delores) quince. And then Lola says that her friend Theresa is mad because her party is the night before hers. I missed why the date is changed. And Tony is coming back for it. There is some HISTORY there.

Sarah heads into Lola’s room and has a heart to heart about…who knows what. I don’t remember. And offers to buy Lola her dream dress for her party.

Tony arrives to his…sister’s (Maria) house? Maria is Theresa’s mother btw. And she doesn’t seem phased about Lola and Theresa’s quince on the same weekend. She seems really happy and friendly.

Tony and his family have a lovely dinner. Then they ask why he hasn’t been home in two years. Are they eating in a bathroom? The echo is insane. Maria says she submitted Theresa’s quince to a magazine so Tony has to cater it.

The next day, Sarah wears the most absurd child’s bike helmet while she rides her oversized child’s bike around. Meanwhile, Tony chats with his parents. And if Tony’s mom keeps hugging him, he’s going to leave before he even has a meet cute with Sarah. Tony takes his dad’s old car to stroll around the “old neighborhood.” Sarah leisurely strolls the farmers market, sniffing everything. Her notebook is IDENTICAL to her dress. WHAT. Then of course she knocks down all the fruit when she notices Tony. So then he rushes over to help her and it’s a super awkward run in. Tony asks her to catch up. She agrees to a walk. Sarah walks her oversized children’s bike as they talk about their old relationship. Apparently they wanted to open a restaurant together but Tony became a big shot. Then they realize they both are catering their nieces’ quinces. Guys. Like so in their early twenties, they were dating and then trying to go into business together? And they had money to do this? And why would they do this as just dating?

Back at the food truck, we get more of the back story. They were both up for a spot at a prestigious culinary school but neither got in. So, instead they BOUGHT a food truck. And THEN Tony found out he got in and bailed on the food truck. Oh this is insanity. Like did she buy him out? Or like what were the details of this? Her friend Kevin encourages her to submit herself for the magazine about quince food.

Tony cooks with his niece and mom back at the house. Matt and Tony finally catch up. Tony wants to eat at Sarah’s place for lunch. He tells his family he apologized so they are all good. Yeah right.

Tony heads to the food truck and I realize it’s called “Munch.” Terrible. Matt tells Tony that Sarah wants to open a new location in South Beach. Tony asks to breakfast the next day. Dang, Tony doesn’t play. Then later, (how much later I don’t know. Time doesn’t seem to be linear in this movie) he discovers that his niece is going to be at the same place as Sarah and her niece the next day (or again, later that same day?). So Tony becomes super helpful and offers to drive or pick whoever up. I don’t know.

The next morning, the girls are all at the dress shop picking up Lola’s dream dress. Apparently all the girls are doing emerald dresses this year. Then Tony shows up and AGAIN, HE. DOESN’T. PLAY. He invites her to dinner. Then Theresa shows up and is mad that Lola picked the same color dress. There is a terse moment with everyone. And then poor Lola decides to get a different color dress.

Oh and now both parties will be in South Florida Quince Style or whatever the magazine is called.

Back at Tony’s house, they do some menu sampling. Then Sarah texts him and asks to talk. He again asks her to dinner. She’s like, is he asking me out? Like what have you been thinking he’s doing the the last 3 times you guys have run into each other? Like every time he talks to her he’s asking her out.

Okay so they meet at the restaurant even though his text said he’d pick her up. Also they are dressed so fancy. Everyone is always so fancy on dates in these movies. A guy comes by and gives them a drink on the house. Tony asks him to sit and hang out for a minute. He tells them he’s selling the restaurant. So this must be Ernesto.

Okay WHAT TIME OF DAY IS IT. They start walking and talking and it’s still light outside. Didn’t they have dinner? And that’s when Sarah finally tells Tony she will be in the magazine too. He’s like cool! Don’t care. Then he tells her that he and his girlfriend broke up. That was what the sad rainy window scene was about earlier.

Alright now what day or time is it? I think it’s the next morning. The lighting is WILD. OMG. Okay so the photo shoot is TOMORROW for this magazine. And now it’s a competition to see who will be on the cover. Yep. That all adds up.

That same day? The chefs are getting organized for the party. Sarah walks up to Tony with her child’s bike. Sarah gives him some unsolicited advice about delegating. They are at her house and she invites him in. They talk about how ridiculous this magazine is. AGREED. She asks him to try her food and for some reason she feeds him. We all feel so uncomfortable. Tony is not impressed and suggests adding something. He wants to add something spicy and then says they should add something sweet too. She suggests MINT. Is she just a terrible chef? Mint? With spicy peppers? And then he suggests they make some Cuban Irish fusion food like they planned to when they were going to have their own restaurant. So we get a little cooking montage.

By that time, it’s finally night for the first time in the movie. They just dive right into the Cuban pot pie. They call it shepard’s pie but it’s a regular pie crust. Oh wait, no it’s not night. The indoor lighting is just cray. And they both think the mint works. I DISAGREE. He then invites her to go dancing with his family that night.

WOW Sarah’s little (and I mean LITTLE) dancing dress. Sarah runs into Maria. Maria wonders how Delores is doing. She doesn’t know why Delores is upset with her. How about because her daughter is a jerk to Delores’s daughter? Anyway, it seems like Maria is going to call her. Then this family gets to dancing. Sarah and Tony sit down and order a drink. He asks why she’s still single. Then they hold hands!

They chat about the good old days in the car on the way home. They talked about their split too. It’s boring. Their whole deal doesn’t make any sense to me but then again, that’s fake Hallmark exes for you.

Sarah invites him in to see the disaster that is Lola’s choreographed dance situation. Tony steps in and offers to help. WHOA. After the dancing he walks her to her door or she walks him to his door or something and THEY KISS. OMG

The next day is the photo shoot. It seems like Maria and Delores are trying to make amends? The chefs do some interviews. They’re in their little chef outfits.

Now it’s photoshoot time. The girls are wearing totally different dresses (not the ones they picked for their party) and they are having fun doing this all together. I’m not sure why the chefs had to be in the photoshoots and why they had to make their own food for this photo shoot. After the photo shoot, the two girls have a good chat. The chefs have a good chat too. Tony tries to get Sarah to go out with him again but she has to work. Like seriously, at every turn. Did he just see her again and was immediately like, okay I want to get back together after not giving this girl a second thought for ten years? Because like I said, HE DOES NOT PLAY. At the food truck, Kevin encourages Sarah to put in an offer for Ernestos.

Kevin calls her AGAIN in the morning and suggests it again. He is up and at it and Sarah was dead asleep. Somehow this regional magazine has a booming web presence and they are advertising the competition between the two cover options. And trying to get the reader to vote on who they like best. And they each said rude stuff about each other apparently? DRAMA. But the magazine misquoted both of them.

Sarah tells Delores she made an offer on Ernestos. It seems she hasn’t really thought through the financing side of the bid. She was like, I just hope the bank will offer me a low rate because I did not double check before submitting my offer. Then Tony comes by to talk about the stupid website. Sarah gives a weird random speech about women in the food industry and Tony is like wait what do I have to do with your ability to finance a restaurant? And then all of a sudden they’re talking about trying to get back together and Sarah is like, no I’m too hurt from last time so no. So that was ALOT.

Lola calls Theresa and they talk about Sarah and Tony and their moms being friends again. They decide to end the family feud. Well GOOD FOR THESE GIRLS.

Tony has a heart to heart with his mom about Sarah. I stopped paying attention during his mom’s speech. It doesn’t matter. Tony does some taste testing at Ernestos. He tells him he wants to make an offer on Ernestos. Ernesto tells Tony that Sarah made an offer. Okay he shouldn’t have told him that and what difference does it make? Shouldn’t he be taking all the offers?

So Ernesto tells him that someone obviously outbid her. So he outbid that person. And then he pitches that they could do it together. She’s like, I haven’t seen you in 10 years and now you want to run a business together? That’s fair. Also he should have talked to her about it.

It’s quince day and the venue calls Matt and says there was a fire in the kitchen so they have to cancel. Oh WAS THERE? Wait, no Lola didn’t try and trick her family. Then Theresa suggests they have a joint quince! That’s what I’m thinking. After a lot of discussion, they all finally agree to it.

It’s quince rehearsal time. Delores says thank you to Maria and she dismissively says “it’s for Lola.” Maria is no nonsense at the rehearsal. The girls ask to practice their speeches and talk about how great their moms were and how much they loved being such close friends. And now they’ve prepared a slide show of them as little girls. It is very moving to the moms. The moms have a heart to heart. Oh and then Delores says she wanted to buy Maria’s house but Maria took a better offer. So she was hurt about that. Maria was like oh it was just business. I wanted more money. But then Maria offers to find them a great house. I mean, like we can all dream right? I don’t know. That’s weird. Then Sarah delivers the blow that the magazine was only into the dueling chef angle of the quince. Because that makes sense.

The night of the big quince, the chefs are working together. Good old Kevin makes the chefs quit for the night so they can enjoy the party. The girls looked so pretty in their dresses! Holy cow how expensive was this party. Then the girls do their dance and it isn’t completely humiliating. And of course now the chefs have to make a speech….as is tradition at a quince.

Sarah and Tony talk after the party? Or during? Who knows. Who cares. She says she might have been too hasty about that restaurant business. He’s like luckily I only asked you this morning and have been too busy to ask anyone else. They agree on a split. 70/30but who’s paying what? Anyway then they kiss. 6 months later, Cubish opens. I love when people start a new business venture and a dating relationship at the same time! I bet that will work out so well!!

So guys. I hated this movie. It was edited so weirdly and it was just alot of Hallmark nonsense. I think it had potential, as they all do. But it was just not it for ol Cal. But again, I JUST WANT TO SEE PEOPLE STROLL THROUGH A PUMPKIN PATCH WITH A PSL. JUST ONE SCENE. Put a vest on one of these ladies. Some boots. A plaid scarf. A fall wreath on the door. AM I ASKING FOR TOO MUCH?!!! Anyway, what did you think?

Love Strikes Twice

Okay so we’ve all been anticipating this one because it looks cute and funny. But, this movie premiered in the “Fall Harvest” line up and there was nary a pumpkin or colored leaf to be had. I don’t understand why these fall movies have not been focused on the season like Christmas and winter movies are. I would Love some fall feels. Sheesh. Anyway, let’s dive in.

We’ve got a busy business woman working while she cooks. Maggie is a no nonsense attorney. She only has time for her cases, not her husband, not personal errands, and not cooking. Her husband Josh has to cancel a class to pick up some anniversary gift for her parents. Girl, ship it! What year is it? Why are either of you running around town picking things up the old fashioned way? She tells her boss that she is leaving early but taking work with her. Oof I would not make it in a big law firm like that. I would just crumble.

Her friend, Keri walks in with a bright pink dress on. I feel like they’re just friends, not coworkers because you would NOT wear a bright pink dress to work at a law firm. Oh she is a friend and client? Okay. Ooof. She had a boyfriend named Lester. She dumped him because of his name. That’s fair, honestly. Maggie vents a little about the pressure of making partner and investing in her marriage. I mean, yes that’s legit. Lots of lawyers end up divorced. Keri tells Maggie she ran into “Rick” downstairs in the lobby. Maggie is surprised that he remembers her and Keri is like, girl you dated all through college. Like why would she be surprised, honestly? Her college boyfriend? Of course he’d remember her. She literally bumps right into him in the lobby and he asks her for coffee. She’s too busy but he wants to meet for lunch next time he’s in town. She looks at him like he’s the one who got away. So what’s that about?

On the way to the anniversary party, Maggie and Josh bicker about work, etc… He asks her to pull over and they reminisce about the old library and what a dump their town is. Josh says Maggie felt sorry for him and that’s why they started dating. Maggie isn’t sure that’s wrong. Hmm. At home, Maggie’s mom says she didn’t feel up for planting flowers in the front yard. Seems ominous. Her dad hobbles down the stairs. Maggie’s brother, Ash pops by. He seems weird. Ugh again with the junior partner thing? Guys, it’s REALLY not a thing. There are a few different kinds of partnerships you can get as a lawyer and “junior” is not one of them.

That evening, Josh asks Maggie what is going on with them. He says her parents still like each other and Josh wonders if they ever should have gotten married. They decide to talk about it when they get back to Chicago. She wonders if she should just sleep in her old room? And then she decides to go for a walk. She sits by a fountain and decides to make a wish. She wishes for a do over. BUT FOR WHAT. She drops her phone and hits her head and then seemingly gets knocked unconscious.

She comes to in her bed…in what looks like her old room. She’s got an old flip phone. She wants to blame Ash for her stupid phone but her mom says she just bought it for her! Her dad comes in from a run and she sees that the calendar says June 2006. What!! Keri calls and Maggie tries to like furiously explain what’s going on and Keri is not having it. RICK is waiting outside in a red sports car. Wait, young Rick looks like grown up Josh. These guys are WAY too similar. Flanigans is back! The restaurant Maggie loved that went out of business. Oh wait Josh is a different guy. Rick and Josh have opposing view points about saving the library. And Josh and Rick may as well be identical twins.

Rick and Maggie head to the beach with all the other youths in 2006. Also the AUDACITY of this movie to FLASH BACK to 2006 as 15 years ago. Poor Rick keeps trying to kiss Maggie but she is not having it. Good for her. Uh oh. Her dad is about to go up on a ladder, which is I believe how he jacked up his back or whatever so she tells him to throw it out. Inside, she goes downstairs to see her weirdo brother. He’s perfect to tell about her weird situation. I love this line about her dreams usually involving Sonia Sotomayor. Ash asks her to tell him something from the future and she almost spoils Game of Thrones before he stops her. I am loving the sibling nonsense as well. Ash posits a theory that makes sense to Maggie. She IMMEDIATELY breaks his Lego contraption. I can’t tell if she does it on purpose.

Maggie tries to force herself back to the present before going to bed. It doesn’t work. The music sure does try! She chats with Rick on the phone. She seems to love it. Again, how is she surprised earlier that he remembered her? Ash asks her if she’s still a time traveler and she fills him in on her present life. Maggie vents a little and asks Ash to come with him to the library rally. She thinks if the library is saved, Josh will be happy and she can be with Rick. Like does she really want to be with Rick? I don’t get it. Ash makes a funny line about how he thought the future would be cool but it’s just her boring drama. I love it. And then she totally like pumps him up about himself in the future. That is really sweet.

Maggie runs into Josh at the rally. He seems REALLY happy to see her. I had low expectations for Ash initially but he’s actually CARRYING this movie. Josh gives a big speech about the library and libraries in general. She asks him what saving this library is all about? Because they’ve already built a new one and moved everything over. That’s a pretty good point, actually. It is purely nostalgia from his childhood. Also this is the FIRST she’s heard of this story. IN FIFTEEN YEARS. Then, the police show up. Maggie says she’s “got it.” And they immediately get arrested. That doesn’t make any sense. And frankly, this whole piece of the story adds some comedy but it would not happen this way and is so wrong across the board. I need to release it but I can’t. Also, no one was wearing that overall situation in 2006. And, her parents are funnier in 2006. They make so many jokes about her being in jail and how the dad wanted a dog and not kids. I love it. Then her parents dance together at a restaurant. They’re ALOT.

Another day in the past. Maggie has to go to court. Her parents are still cracking jokes about going to jail. Maggie thinks because she practices corporate law she knows criminal law. I am guessing these guys were charged with misdemeanors? Oh she called it an infraction. Which is LESS than a misdemeanor. It’s like, taking your case to traffic court. Which is what this whole proceeding would be like. Evidence? And they have a permit!! End of story! All she had to say was that they had a permit. That would have settled the whole thing before they got to the police station. UGH okay. That’s just not how any of this works. I just… Okay. It’s fine. Anyway in a round about way the judge dismisses the case. Then Maggie makes a case to the judge about the library. She wants to file a temporary restraining order to stop the library demolition. The judge is just tickled with Maggie. Well, she’s been practicing law for ten years so maybe she should chill. But the judge grants them a 14 day restraining order against demolition.

Rick shows up at the court house and he is like a total jerk. He gets all territorial of Maggie and apparently his dad is upset that he’s dating a “jail bird.” And the dad has requested a dinner with her that night. And then Keri asks if she can ask Josh out and Maggie says okay. Guys, I just need to get this out here. There are a handful of noticeably terrible actors in this movie but I also think they are likely doing their best with the dialogue they’ve been given. But it is pretty absurd and noticeable.

Oh dear. Rick’s dad is the worst. He gives Maggie a real “talking to” about the jail business and helping save the library. The dad shares that he is planning to invest in the new project that is replacing the library. But we found out earlier that the developers of the new building took the investors’ money and ran. Rick seems like a total pushover and just wants to keep the peace. Maggie holds her ground. Good for her! But I would die. I actually don’t understand why she likes Rick though. He mostly seems annoying and a bit of a wet sandwich.

At home, Maggie and her mom look at old photos. Maggie asks how she knew her dad was “the one.” And her mom gives LEGITIMATELY GOOD ADVICE. Like if there is just this “one” that means you don’t have to work at it. And love is a choice. Maggie decides to head to Flanigans to get banana cream pie. Girl, pick a different flavor, gross. At Flanigans, she sees Josh and Keri having just a fantastic time.

Maggie runs into Ash and he is VERY CONFIDENT. He has a date with “Veronica.” Maggie panics when she hears this and tells her mom he can’t date her because she basically destroys him and he never recovers. That adds up. She comes downstairs and JOSH is there.

Maggie is muttering to herself about helping him meet with some lawyers in Chicago about saving the library. I believe its her old firm. Yes, it is. Her boss is not yet partner and is “senior counsel” on this case. Baxter, her boss, offers Josh a stipend for his trouble and his nostalgia. Pretty fair considering their ONLY argument to save this building is his personal memories. It sounds like there are legitimate historical reasons for preserving the building but no one has actually articulated those in a setting where it matters. So, Maggie rips up the first number. He writes another number and slowly slides it down the table. It’s hilarious. Is it bad that I am kind of rooting for the developer (forgetting that he will eventually defraud the town)? They already have a NEW LIBRARY. It’s not like they’re losing a library.

Baxter grabs Maggie after the meeting. He is still trying to pay her off. Since they have not articulated any legitimate reason or claim for saving the library, I am surprised he’s going so hard. He is kind of mean to her! She suggests he look into his client more. Guess what? He does not.

Now it’s time for the trial. Maybe the next day? Because that’s how it works. Ugh. The whole court proceeding is nonsense. Except for when Maggie tries to talk about the developer’s intentions. Unfortunately, she doesn’t have any proof yet. Surely his financial records are a mess? Shouldn’t she have filed a discovery motion? Is this an actual complaint to prevent the development contract with the city or just an injunction to temporarily stop demolition while they litigate the merits? Anyway, she loses the case and she’s bummed.

Rick is waiting outside the courthouse and he wants to take her to dinner. At dinner, Rick is REALLY worried about his dad’s feelings on this whole business. He is like, maybe now my dad will forgive you and let’s not mess stuff up for him. He is kind of a small little wet sandwich of a man. Ha! He thinks he’s capable of being part of a power couple? He is so weak! Oh dang he’s proposing? And she accepts? WHAT DOES SHE SEE IN THIS GUY? And he proposes at a restaurant? Like I have yet to see one thing interesting or likable. Oh and her parents haven’t even met him? He didn’t talk to them first? He waits outside all the time and never comes to the door. YOU GUYS. Like why? I feel like she would have noticed right away what a little weasel he is but she is like, yeah! Rick is the guy!

That night, she finds Josh at the library. He notices the ring and congratulates her. He gives another big speech and says he loves her! They have a deep conversation and Maggie is talking from the perspective of 15 years on about their relationship. He asks if Rick is the one and she smiles and says yeah. WHY DOES SHE LIKE HIM. He asks her about the wedding and that triggers her memory about the developer. She wonders about his financials. Didn’t I like, suggest she do that before her trial? But, she only had like one day to prepare instead of the typical 1-3 years so I shouldn’t be too hard on her. Anyway, they decide to sneak in to the country club the next day to get a peek.

The next day, the heist is on. They wear country club employee shirts and Josh freaks about wearing someone’s else’s clothes. It’s pretty hilarious. They get a key from the security guard to get into all the lockers. This is all very easy. What are these two kids up to? Oh they are inspecting all the lockers to find the developer’s (Michael) briefcase WITH ALL HIS FINANCIAL INFORMATION. Idiots. He’s going to have that with him? But, apparently not. He does in fact carry ALL his important fraudulent documents with him in his briefcase and stores it in the locker room of this country club. So yeah, this is the guy you want overseeing a major development in town. I love the heist music in the background. They grab the briefcase and take the contents to make copies. Josh is an idiot. He stops to text Maggie instead of just getting to work. Maggie gets scolded by a woman playing tennis. This woman is in the middle of her tennis match and runs over to Maggie and tells her the laundry/towel bin has been full for 20 minutes. Like lady do you really need the towel bin emptied while you’re playing? You have to stop your game to scold Maggie? Sheesh. Out on the course, Michael Williams hurts himself. Then Maggie stops to reply to Josh. Why would she text right in the same place as she got scolded? Meanwhile, Josh makes a mess of himself in the copy room and jams the printer. He…bless his heart. Maggie stalls by trying to call in a heart attack on an emergency phone line outside for Michael. She buys them a little time. Then, she almost runs into Rick et al, while Josh tries to load the briefcase back in the locker. Josh almost gets caught too but he is willing to be a real weirdo for the sake of not showing his face. They make it out of there!

That night, Maggie has a whole crew working on the data. One of the girls, Tracy, notices a discrepancy. Maggie wink wink tells her to definitely not hack into the accounts and sends her downstairs to ask Ash for help. I love when the lead plays wingman!

Alright, so they are back at court. The judge. Oof. Doing her best with her material. Anyway, Maggie’s strategy is to present the information she obtained without having to explain how she found it. She could have filed a discovery request like earlier?! I need to stop. Maggie gets “highly offended” which is her strategy to avoid explaining how she found the material. I’m releasing this whole court room business. Michael Williams seems to realize he’s been caught. And then the assertion that the documents were obtained illegally basically proves that they do belong to Michael so that backfired. So they win! After the case, Baxter pulls Maggie aside and offers a recommendation for law school and possibly a spot at his firm. She’s like, nah I’m good.

Maggie and Josh hug outside. For a long time. Ash pushes them away from each other. I love it. Then she makes Josh drive over her dad’s ladder to break it.

The next morning? It’s still 2006 and Maggie is inexplicably STILL engaged. And it is the night of her parents’ 25th anniversary party. They like to have BIG parties for their anniversaries apparently. Keri tells Maggie that Josh is in love with someone else. Oh, who could that be?

Rick the wet sandwich approaches Maggie at the party. Maggie thinks Rick is going to apologize and that his dad is going to be so happy about saving his money. But Rick says his dad is mad about being proven wrong. And Rick is like, I thought we were just going to be doing what my dad wanted? Like for everything? So Maggie dumps him. FINALLY. She finally sees how lame this guy is. Then Maggie sees Josh and runs toward him and slips on the dance floor. She wakes up at her parents’ 40TH Anniversary! Keri is dating a doctor instead of Lester. Fingers crossed for poor Keri. And Ash is married to Tracy! And they’re having a baby! And living with Palo Alto which means he must be a fancy software developer or whatever. And Maggie and Josh don’t live in Chicago. They live in their hometown. Oh that was a twist on a classic I didn’t see coming. And her dad isn’t crippled! Maggie and Josh stroll through town and see the “library” which turned into her social justice law firm. That’s a pretty big building for what can’t amount to much work in a small town. Anyway, they kiss again and that’s the end of it.

Okay so you guys this movie was absurd. ABSOLUTELY absurd. There was ALOT of classic Hallmark nonsense. But guess what? The PREMISE of this movie requires us to go along with the idea that a person can make a wish, hit their head, and go back in time. So I really do need to release it when they get other things wrong in the plot if I’m going along for the ride here. Surprisingly, this movie had a lot of humor. Like, ALOT for a Hallmark movie, which, in my opinion, TOTALLY saved the movie and made it real fun to watch. Did I ask yet why this movie was included in the “Fall Harvest” line up when it takes place in the SUMMER? Is there going to be an actual fall movie or what? Anyway, I liked this one. What did you think?